4 ms·
"They are rarely grounded in an ideology cannily crafted from first principles. Like most of our beliefs, the reasons for political convictions are constructed
by mlevental 7y ago
"They are rarely grounded in an ideology cannily crafted from first principles. Like most of our beliefs, the reasons for political convictions are constructed after we have settled on them.[5] Attempts to make the tangle of positions endorsed by Republicans or Democrats congeal into one coherent ideology are post-hoc justifications. Ideological coherence ultimately matters less than commitment to a coalition."
is `values` synonymous with `beliefs` here? if so, isn't coalitionism a first principle itself? and therefore really what's happening is there's a hierarchy of beliefs and primary beliefs (such as loyalty, faith, etc.) inform secondary (more fungible) beliefs/political interests.
personally i have throughout my life heard people say things to that effect ("god, family, country"). it has stood in stark contrast to how i've felt (because i didn't grow up religious, don't have close family ties, am an immigrant - so not patriotic) and as a consequence (i hypothesize) affects the way in which i approach politics, in that i try to reason things out from first principles.
- nine_k 7y agoStaying in power is the first principle. Most of the rest is post hoc rationalization. Look at it from a game-theoretic angle. Your moves may increase your chance to stay in power, increase your chance to get to the power, or symmetrically decrease either chance. You can choose to always act to increase the chance to be in power, or sometimes decrease it willingly because of your values. At every turn, some players leave (e.g. due to age), and some new players with either strategy join the game. I posit that the concentration of players in power with the "anything for power" strategy will be higher on average than of players in power with "sometimes risk power for values" strategy. With a low enough rate of losing power due to external causes (not the strategy), the concentration of "anything for power" players staying in power may become very high, up to 100% sometimes.