3 ms·
Good. This might actually be the one good thing that Trump has accomplished. Or that would have been my reaction until I read the article: "Countries with mor
by mcv 7y ago
Good. This might actually be the one good thing that Trump has accomplished.
Or that would have been my reaction until I read the article:
"Countries with more than 75,000 tonnes in post imported annually - mainly the United States - may apply their self-declared new rates from July 2020, UPU officials said."
So does 'mainly the US' mean 'only the US'? I don't want an exception just for the US because they are too powerful to ignore, I want the same rule to hold for every EU country. Replacing a rule where rich countries subsidize long distance mail from (former) poor countries with a rule where only small rich countries have to pay for that subsidy is really not an improvement.
- TMWNN 7y agoTrump is president of the United States, not of the EU. It is the EU and its member states' onus to obtain similar changes, should they believe them desirable. That you begin with a snarky remark about Trump, and then go on to say that he is at fault for not helping Belgium or Austria win the kind of changes that the US needed to seriously threaten to leave the UPU for, says more about you than about the US or Trump.
- mcv 7y agoI'm not sure how you think the UPU works, but Trump does not set UPU rules on his own. 200 countries are involved in those negotiations. If the UPU rules are inconsistent, that's not just on Trump, but on the UPU and the many parties negotiating in it, including the EU. So I have no idea why you choose to read my complaint about the UPU negotiations as a complaint about Trump. I even started out by saying he is right in this one case. But this is an issue that's not unique to the US, but to all wealthy countries, and therefore should be handled evenly for all countries. That's what I pointed out in my comment. You're a bit too eager to read attacks where there are none. Had the UPU made just a single exception for the US because of the US's power, that would have been inconsistent and a mistake by the UPU. But as others have explained elsewhere, that's not what happened. The rule is for everybody, it just starts 6 months early for the US, which I guess is a minor gesture to appease Trump. I'm fine with that. Starting in 2021, the situation will be fixed for everybody.
- TMWNN 7y agoI love your rushing to pretend that you didn't write what you wrote: >Good. This might actually be the one good thing that Trump has accomplished. >Or that would have been my reaction until I read the article: >"Countries with more than 75,000 tonnes in post imported annually - mainly the United States - may apply their self-declared new rates from July 2020, UPU officials said." >So does 'mainly the US' mean 'only the US'? I don't want an exception just for the US because they are too powerful to ignore, I want the same rule to hold for every EU country. Replacing a rule where rich countries subsidize long distance mail from (former) poor countries with a rule where only small rich countries have to pay for that subsidy is really not an improvement. In other words: * Requisite snarky remark about Trump * Complaint that the rule change is only for the US (written before you read the rest of the thread and realize that this refers to the US getting the rule change slightly earlier than other countries, as we can see by ...) * Stating that "this is not an improvement" because other rich countries won't benefit from the rule change, again because you hadn't yet read the read of the thread. (Even were you correct, this would be an improvement for the US, which is Trump's concern. As I said, he is not the president of the EU.)
- mcv 7y agoI'm not pretending I didn't write what I wrote. I did write what I wrote. I didn't write what you claim I wrote: > "then go on to say that he is at fault for not helping Belgium or Austria" That is not something I wrote. I never said Trump is at fault for these results. That is something you're trying to put in my mouth, and I'm telling you not to do that, because it's a dishonest way of arguing. If you're looking for bad things to blame on Trump, there's tons of that around. This is one of those very rare things where he actually did the right thing. And had the UPU only made this an exception for the US, and not changed the rules for everybody, that would have been on the UPU as a whole and presumably the EU members who failed to negotiate this properly. Fortunately that's not what happened; it was a misunderstanding on my part (based on a cursory reading of the article, so I was already hoping it was the article or my reading of it that was wrong).
- TMWNN 7y ago