4 ms·
If they're in a solar system, they could keep devouring rocks and mini-planets to keep existing, no?
by BurningFrog 7y ago
If they're in a solar system, they could keep devouring rocks and mini-planets to keep existing, no?
- dreamcompiler 7y agoYes. They'd mostly be sustained by the solar wind.
- saagarjha 7y agoI’m sure that would give off huge amounts of gamma radiation.
- sudhirj 7y agoOnly when they cleared their orbits, around the beginning of the solar system. Doubt they'd see much impact now.
- saagarjha 7y agoEarth is hit by a couple dozen tons of space material a day.
- sliken 7y agoCan't reply directly to the child. The earth is quite larger than a black hole with an earth mass. Also the earth has a huge atmosphere to help capture things. A black hole with the same mass as the earth would be almost impossible to hit in comparison (9mm). No atmosphere to slow things down, very hard to hit, and you have to come within 1.5 * the radius before you can't escape without thrust. So sure, some dust would be capture, but nothing anywhere close to what the earth captures a day.
- sliken 7y agoActually even a moon mass blackhole (0.1mm) would be sustained just by the CMB background. Anything more than that would increase it's mass (and diameter).
- raducu 7y agoCouldn't we somehow shield it and wait for it to produce energy eventually?
- sliken 7y agoSure, possible. But the timescales involved are daunting, as is the energy/tech required to shield a blackhole with sometime so efficient that the temperature gets down below 1 kelvin. It's not all that much energy for the timescales involved, you'd be better off just putting say an acre of solar panels in orbit around the sun. Tiny blackholes are amazing efficient engines for turning mass into energy, once small enough they could be quite a power plant and not picky about what you feed them.
- Sharlin 7y agoAn Earth mass black hole has a Schwarzschild radius of about 9mm. It would devour mostly CMB photons, individual gas molecules, and very rarely small dust particles.
- BurningFrog 7y agoThanks for teaching me how tiny it would be. I had no idea! With the gravity of a whole planet it would still attract a lot of stray matter. I don't know how many collisions that would generate though. Mostly just deflected orbits and captured satellites, I assume. But surely a lot more than a "regular matter" 9mm pellet.
- Sharlin 7y agoYes, it would whisk small stuff around, and affect the orbits of Kuiper belt bodies just like the hypothetical Planet Nine is theorized to do. It would give a big kick to any objects that happened to pass very close by, but such encounters would be extremely rare. I don’t think the density of tiny stuff is enough for an accretion disc to form around it, but could be wrong. If one did form, we would probably detect its radiation signature.