4 ms·
His comment is relevant to the linked article. The author felt it was important enough to bring up, so why isn't it a relevant topic of discussion? To expand o
by gamblor956 7y ago
His comment is relevant to the linked article. The author felt it was important enough to bring up, so why isn't it a relevant topic of discussion?
To expand on that: Atlas shrugged is about purported geniuses being oppressed and denied the freedom to create and make money from their own inventions. But the author didn't create anything, they just slapped a logo on someone else's products.
IOW, Cognitive dissonance between the supposed inspirations of the author and their actual behavior. Just like a certain CEO that just resigned.
- dang 7y agoNot everything an article mentions is relevant to bring up. The question is always what sort of discussion it leads to. If it leads to ragey indignation, ideological battle, snark, personal attacks, and other baddies, then following the HN guidelines means having the discipline not to go there. The alternative is to let yourself be trolled by arbitrary provocations and then to troll HN in turn by bringing them into the threads here. I don't mean "troll" in its original sense of intentionally manipulating discussion, but in the sense that those are the effects we end up with. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html