4 ms·
Putting more dies closer together makes thermal issues worse. Hot parts next to other hot parts increase thermal power density, more heat to remove from a smal
by nine_k 7y ago
Putting more dies closer together makes thermal issues worse.
Hot parts next to other hot parts increase thermal power density, more heat to remove from a small area.
Colder parts next to hot parts can overheat because of the hot neighbors.
I suspect water cooling may become a must, air just cannot take away enough heat.
- pingyong 7y agoAir is gonna do fine. The bottleneck in CPU cooling right now is pretty much always the transfer between the die, the heat spreader and the cooling plate, not the transfer from the fins to the air. Water cooling can do slightly better because you can keep the water cool, and with that the cooling plate, and through that increase the heat flow from the CPU to the plate, but it's really only marginally better than a big air cooler. And if you put more dies below a heat spreader, you get more surface area, i.e. better heat flow overall (compared to a single die with the same power consumption) from the dies to the heat spreader and from the heat spreader to the cooling plate. That's also the reason why bigger air coolers don't really do as much as you'd think they should in terms of cooling performance or overclocking, the difference between an NH-U14S and an NH-D15 is really quite small. If the problem is heat dissipation through the fins all you have to do is make the cooler bigger.
- nine_k 7y agoYou can bring water closer to the crystal, and make it pass faster past / inside the dissipator plate, thus achieving a larger stream of heat. Effectively you can turn the dissipation plate into moving liquid with high specific thermal capacity (5-7x of the metal plate).
- tenebrisalietum 7y agoPut the darn thing in mineral oil or other heat-conductive liquid and have a radiator dissipate that heat? Wouldn't that be easier if everything's on a big wafer? It's already been done for a normal motherboard.
- jabl 7y agoWater has the big advantage that it's plentiful, cheap, and environmentally benign. Sure, it'll take some more upfront engineering to design a system/rack/datacenter for water cooling than just immersing a server in a tank of inert liquid (flourinert or whatever they use these days), but I'm quite sure that at some point water cooling will be the standard solution in data centers.