4 ms·
Apparently this is a picture of ultraprocessed foods: https://static.scientificamerican.com/sciam/assets/Image/2019/scientificamerican1019-38-I3.jpg https://sta
by dragontamer 7y ago
Apparently this is a picture of ultraprocessed foods: https://static.scientificamerican.com/sciam/assets/Image/2019/scientificamerican1019-38-I3.jpg https://static.scientificamerican.com/sciam/assets/Image/201...
This seems like nonsense. There's baby formula in the top right corner: were they really feeding baby formula to grown adults in the lab trials?
Or did the authors of this piece just grab a bunch of foods from the grocery store and assumed they were related to the study?
I want a link to the actual study. Pictures like the above just piss me off. There's a lot of issues in health-reporting and diet reporting. Lots of "Ultraprocessed" discussion going on, but there's no definition of what "ultraprocessed" is.
--------
EDIT: Here's the next photo:
https://static.scientificamerican.com/sciam/assets/Image/2019/scientificamerican1019-38-I4(1).jpg https://static.scientificamerican.com/sciam/assets/Image/201...
Are you seriously telling me that __canned peas__ are highly processed? That's ridiculous. Especially in the face of highly-refined, enriched, white-flour in the "unprocessed" food picture.
Look: I get that Spam and frozen-pizza are "ultraprocessed" foods. But canned peas and Goya chickpeas are processed? Who made these photographs? They fed Spam to people in hospital, and these images are drawing conclusions about canned peas.
-------------
I think there's something to be said about "Spam is bad for you" (actual study) vs "We fed Spam to 20 people in a hospital for 2 weeks, and we've concluded that Frosted Flakes and canned peas are bad for you". Unfortunately, this article feels a lot like the latter conclusion.
- agentdrtran 7y agoSA either just used these stock images or their graphics person threw it together, I wouldn't guess it has any real link to the study.
- Lazare 7y agohttps://www.cell.com/cms/10.1016/j.cmet.2019.05.008/attachment/f7d43756-3f67-4557-8322-59a9d143d63c/mmc1 https://www.cell.com/cms/10.1016/j.cmet.2019.05.008/attachme... There's a PDF of the actual menu, although it's just as random. Apparently wheat flour pasta is unprocessed, but a wheat flour tortilla is ultra-processed, sure, okay.
- dragontamer 7y agoDay 1 Dinner: Canned Corn (Giant brand) is considered "ultraprocessed". Wow. I appreciate the link. Honestly, seeing the menu makes me think it is somewhat quackery. But it seems like Scientific American really did represent this study correctly. The main thing I've noticed is that the "ultraprocessed" foods are low in fiber, and they try to make it up with large doses of "NutriSource Fiber" pretty much every day. There are exceptions: Canned Corn (wtf?) makes it on the list of "ultraprocessed", and has decent fiber from my memory. A few days later they have beans + beef. But otherwise, the primary source of fiber in that diet is artificial Nutrisource Fiber. Dietary Fiber is core towards feeling full. Its no secret to me (at least) that more fibrous foods (even when low in calories) fill me up quicker than fiber-free foods. I can eat 2 or 3 500+ calorie donuts for example, but trying to eat 800-calories worth of "ultraprocessed" canned corn (that's 1.5 kg / 3.3 pounds of corn) is simply infeasible in one sitting. Or to put it another way: 800 calories in corn is roughly 3x 8.5 oz cans of corn. Still "ultraprocessed" (lol) according to this study, but its going to be way healthier than drinking diet lemonaid with Nutrisource Fiber.
- Lazare 7y agoYeah, just some very odd choices. And quite a unpleasant menu to be honest.