6 ms·
Some ideas about what might be going on: Confirmation bias: people who try new diets and hate them probably talk about it a lot less. Placebo: people getting
by colechristensen 7y ago
Some ideas about what might be going on:
Confirmation bias: people who try new diets and hate them probably talk about it a lot less.
Placebo: people getting caught up hearing about how everyone with their diet feels so much better are convinced they feel better too
Gut fauna: any change, regardless of what it was, causing a population shuffling inside the gut
Avoiding "something": any change, regardless of what it was, involved exclusion of one specific thing which was a sensitivity/allergy/poorly digested/feeding a particular gut bacteria
Thoughtfulness: any change required people to be much more conscientious about what they ate which led to different habits, one of which was critical to feeling better
Lies and exaggerations: diet and nutrition has become a kind of religion replacing God in an increasingly atheist society, some people act with strange quasi-religious zeal for their personal health belief set
I tend to not believe anything anybody says about nutrition. Evidence for anything fits into three categories: guessing, anecdotes, extremely specific cause-and-effect studies without real-world conclusions. The fourth category of believable, properly blinded, controlled, long term human studies does exist but the volume is very low.
- raverbashing 7y agoThere's a simpler explanation: processed foods are more caloric per weight and/or they tend to increase portion size as well.
- colechristensen 7y agoWhat exactly is a processed food? That's a name thrown around like a bad word by nutrition fans everywhere but it seems to mean "food we don't like".
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jodrellblank 7y agoYou can argue that processing food doesn't change anything about it, but it seems a ridiculous position to take that "processed food" might not exist. Do you really see no possible difference between a potato, and Pringles, because "picking potatoes is a process"?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- colechristensen 7y agoI'm challenging it as nonspecific, unhelpful name-calling. What is the difference between "processed" and "cooked" food? Can you really draw a non-arbitrary line between the two? Does it just have to be cooked by someone else? Are there techniques which are kosher and are just "cooked" while others make it "processed"? Is it a set of ingredients which make the distinction? Does baking soda make a food processed? Sodium citrate? Soy lecithin? Could you go through Modernist Cuisine and classify each recipe as "processed" or not?
- jodrellblank 7y agoSo you are doing that? > Can you really draw a non-arbitrary line between the two? No, I can't. That doesn't mean there is no distinction between the two. I cannot draw an arbitrary line where "low altitude" becomes "high altitude", but there are many differences between them. > What is the difference between "processed" and "cooked" food? Cooked is food you would make yourself. Processed is what a company would make to sell to maximise money. Cooked is heating to make digestible and tasty. Processed is trying to find a hyperstimulus to make more-ish. Cooked is food taken as a whole. Processed is treating food as resource to be refined into separate components, then ignore all the non-profitable components and concentrate the obviously useful ones. Cooked is food you bought fresh yesterday and eat leftovers of tomorrow. Processed is food that entered the supply chain two weeks ago and is best before two weeks away. Cooked is food that you trimmed the manky parts off while peeling. Processed is 5 tons of tomatoes dumped onto the ground by a truck. Cooked is food with color. Processed is yellow and white crunchy flour. Cooked is stuff a human can make. Processed is filtered by what fits in a factory process. Cooked uses whatever ingredients are available now. Processed uses only ingredients are available in bulk year round. Cooked is food of different varieties and textures. Processed is the same experience every time. Again, I'm not saying this is automatically bad, I'm saying there is clearly some distinction between "chicken breast bought from a butcher and grilled" and "mechanically recovered processed chicken style textured sandwich filling packaged in a protective atmosphere in plastic with a weird smell to it use within 24 hours of opening", even if I can't pinpoint a non-arbitrary line.
- notJim 7y agoI think scientists use something called the NOVA food classification. If you do some google searches, you can find information, but I haven't found anything that feels really definitive.
- abacadaba 7y agoFwiw, I'm a big proponent of the thoughtfulness theory.
- satyrnein 7y agoI also read the point once that sort of by definition, if a person is overweight, then the person's current diet is not working. So changing to basically anything else is likely an improvement.