4 ms·
> When your entire argument is based on a very basic, widely used logical fallacy no one is going to take it seriously. Like assuming a product has always-on d
by bdcravens 7y ago
> When your entire argument is based on a very basic, widely used logical fallacy no one is going to take it seriously.
Like assuming a product has always-on data mining?
- okmokmz 7y agoNo, not at all. That's a straw man argument. I never said that the product has always-on data mining and you're attempting to use that to invalidate my initial comment. If you have any genuine, logical arguments let me know but you're just attacking a viewpoint you seem to disagree with using blatant fallacious questions and statements
- bdcravens 7y agoYour comment: " ... now my data can be harvested wherever I go instead of just in the privacy of my own home" Two points: 1. How do you know what harvesting takes place? 2. IF it is occurring, how has the status quo changed? The comment seem to make some strong assumptions about what these glasses are doing, without any substantiation.
- okmokmz 7y ago>1. How do you know what harvesting takes place I'm basing my assumption on the wealth of information already available about Amazon and Alexa >2. IF it is occurring, how has the status quo changed? As I already said, now it can occur in public rather than simply in people's homes, and affect bystanders who have not chosen to utilize alexa devices
- bdcravens 7y agoI'd love to respond, but you'll just say "Whataboutism!" Good chat.
- okmokmz 7y agoIf you're going to say I can't care about my privacy in relation to Alexa because of some other unrelated privacy concern then yes, it would be a whataboutism and I would call you out on it, as I would in any debate, because that is how civilized discourse works. If you have a genuine, logical argument I'd like to discuss. Unfortunately most people on this site seem to like downvoting relevant points they feel emotional about and arguing without actually making any effort to understand anyone else's point.
- basch 7y agoshouting "logical fallacy" is not how debate works. using knowledge of fallacy to illustrate the underlying logical error in someones argument is how debate works. you should never actually need to reference a fallacy out loud during debate.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- okmokmz 7y agoIf there was more to your initial comment I could have said more, but you essentially said 'whatabaout you having a smartphone' and that was it. The sole argument was fallacious, and there was nothing more I could reply to...
- basch 7y agoI didnt say that. That was someone else. I think everyone else understood the implication of "but you already have a camera and microphone in your pocket, what additional privacy violation does this cause above and beyond everyone's phones." The poster likely thought it didnt need to be spelled out.
- dang 7y agoCan you please not do tit-for-tat flamewars like this on HN? They're ultra tedious, and you broke the site guidelines repeatedly. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html