3 ms·
Do people benefit from gaming the system? Then it surely is being gamed. And they do. Funding and tenure depend on these metrics. > Overwhelmed by the volume o
by tgv 7y ago
Do people benefit from gaming the system? Then it surely is being gamed. And they do. Funding and tenure depend on these metrics.
> Overwhelmed by the volume of submissions, editors at these journals may choose safety over risk and select papers written by only well-known, experienced researchers.
There is a bit of a "circle jerk" in this process: if you know the right people, you can get better reviews. In return, you review their papers or requests favorably. That also leads to repeating authors.
- hughzhang 7y agoSometimes people idealize academia though. It's important to realize that everything has its flaws :).
- erichocean 7y agoThe thing to realize about academia is that the vast majority of people in it have never experienced the real world. They went straight from grade school to college to working in academia, and stay there until they retire or die. Academia is literally all these people know, and they've been sheltered their entire lives. No one should be surprised that this produces strange results. Obviously there are exceptions, but there's no denying it produces some interesting world views.
- reubens 7y agoSpot on. I like to think that the system-gaming doesn't necessarily disadvantage the committed and passionate researcher (who researches to satisfy personal curiosity).
- marmaduke 7y ago'circle jerk' is hardly the right term, this is more like mafia, insider ism, or maybe just normal human behzvior