4 ms·
No, tapes become preferable to HDDs at less than 100 TB written, not at multiple petabytes. For many applications and for many people, including for myself in m
by adrian_b 7y ago
No, tapes become preferable to HDDs at less than 100 TB written, not at multiple petabytes. For many applications and for many people, including for myself in my home, it makes absolutely no sense to use HDDs for anything, but only SSDs & tapes. For long term storage tape is superior in every way to HDDs, while for fast access SSDs are superior in every way to HDDs.
Obviously, because the drives are extremely expensive, whoever needs no more than 20 or 30 TB of storage cannot afford tapes and must use a few HDDs. The best storage technology changes in time. 20 years ago I was using optical disks and 10 years ago I was using HDDs, but since I went back to tapes, like I was previously using 30 years ago, I have saved a lot of money and I have much less worries about the HDDs becoming defective.
- FrozenVoid 7y agoHow does it compare with 8TB USB3 drives(140$)? https://pcpartpicker.com/product/YpJtt6/western-digital-elements-8tb-external-hard-drive-wdbwlg0080hbk-nesn https://pcpartpicker.com/product/YpJtt6/western-digital-elem...
- adrian_b 7y agoLTO-7 tapes are $10 per TB at Amazon (of course uncompressed), so they are still cheaper, but this $17.50 USD per TB is indeed the cheapest HDD that I have ever seen. Nevertheless, these HDDs are much more expensive than they look at the first glance. The real cost of archival storage is given by the price per TB and per warranty year, because after the warranty time you must replace the storage medium. I have seen countless HDDs that have died just a few months after their warranty time expired. So these drives with 2-year warranty cost $8.75 per TB and per year. The warranty time of the tapes is 30 years, but in fact you must replace them much faster because you will no longer find tape drives able to read them. For LTO tapes, you should expect to replace them after 6 to 10 years. Even with only a 6 year lifetime, the price for tape would be $1.67 per TB per year, i.e. more than 5 times cheaper than those WD HDDs. If you want to just have some backups against accidents, which you expect to erase after a few weeks, then those HDDs could be a good choice. For archival purposes they are still much more expensive than tapes.