3 ms·
Suppose that you are the subject of a public interest story, where you randomly witch-hunted as, let's say, a 'pedo guy'. Suppose that once the dust settles, t
by vkou 7y ago
Suppose that you are the subject of a public interest story, where you randomly witch-hunted as, let's say, a 'pedo guy'.
Suppose that once the dust settles, the facts turn out to be entirely in your favor, and a the publications that ran hit pieces against you quietly issue retractions.
What will happen when I search Google for '6gvONxR4sf7o'? Maybe because you are interviewing to work for me?
I'm going to be bombarded with three pages of search results that loudly proclaim you to be a criminal, a moral degenerate, and possibly even a horse thief.
Is it in the public interest for incorrect information about you to be an incredibly prominent part of your public record?
(Bonus points: You can run a lucrative business by poisoning someone's search results, by, say, including their name and alleged wrong-doings in a 'mugshot database', and then demanding that the target pay you money to get removed from this 'mugshot database'... Should search engines be allowed to play their part in this form of extortion?)
- __david__ 7y agoI don't really find arguments like yours persuasive. Why should there be such a wide, sweeping law for something that's so obviously a corner case? It's not like there are millions of people being publicly "witch-hunted" every year… What's the everyday use case for this? Getting off of marketing mailing lists?
- pgcj_poster 7y agoWhy should there be laws against mass-murder? Hardly anyone does that.
- stevenhuang 7y agoBut that's just the thing: I don't recall there being laws specifically against "mass murder". It'd just be multiple counts of murder. I could be wrong though.
- vkou 7y agoIt's not a corner case. It happens all the time. Also, 'mugshot indexes' that extort money from you are a big business. Search engines should not be cooperating with, and profiting off that racket.
- robdachshund 7y agoYou seem to be totally oblivious of the cancellation culture we now live in
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 7y agoI agree with you, but think it might be an orthogonal question. I'm saying we could resolve the indexer question transitively. You're talking about the content question, where I agree you should be able to set the record straight. That one's a can of worms, so I tried to sidestep it.