3 ms·
Reading patents is hard, but the patent in question is easy because it's so short, and the lawsuit is explicitly saying which claim they believe is in violation
by jcranmer 7y ago
Reading patents is hard, but the patent in question is easy because it's so short, and the lawsuit is explicitly saying which claim they believe is in violation. Here is the claim in full:
> A method performed by an image-capturing mobile device, comprising:
> receiving a plurality of photographic images;
> filtering the plurality of photographic images using a transfer criteria wherein the transfer criteria is a subject identification of a respective photographic image within the plurality of photographic images, wherein the subject identification is based on a topic, theme or individual shown in the respective photographic image;
> and transmitting, via a wireless transmitter and to a second image capturing device, the filtered plurality of photographic images.
IANAL, and I am not sufficiently well-versed in patent law to know precisely how the terminology is to be interpreted in court, but that last element of the claim is really hard to substantiate. First, there's no evidence that it's transmitting via a wireless transmitter (if it doesn't, it can't violate the claim by definition!). Second, there is strong evidence that the destination is not a "second image capturing device." If that last clause is not violated, then the claim is not violated, and the patent is not violated.
From the way the patent claims are constructed, it feels like the patent examiner narrowed the patent to cover specifically wireless point-to-point transmission of images. I don't think the court will look kindly on the broad interpretation being used here.
- KibbutzDalia 7y ago> Reading patents is hard You’d think that would keep all the brilliant legal minds on HN from commenting on it! I appreciate your analysis of it. You’re one of the few here who did read it.
- Spivak 7y agoPatents are written in an intentionally obtuse and difficult to parse way. They're pretty much written in the style of an 11th grader who is overdoing the thesaurus to try and sound smart while conveying as little actual meaning as possible. It's not like you actually want your competitors to be able to reproduce your idea -- you just want the protections.