39 ms·
I was accused of having a hidden agenda and then blocked by the Senior Director of Browser Engineering at Mozilla for suggesting that building DoH into Firefox
by ocdtrekkie 7y ago
I was accused of having a hidden agenda and then blocked by the Senior Director of Browser Engineering at Mozilla for suggesting that building DoH into Firefox and bypassing the OS network stack was a significant concern. This person expressed some bizarre lack of understanding of how DNS works, how OSes work, etc. for such a position, as they seemed to suggest that the only way Mozilla could impact DNS requests is at the browser level, and that implementing it at the OS level wouldn't protect people from ISPs snooping?
Not only will Firefox's approach cause significant breakage, but the fact that it doesn't protect non-browser traffic means users may mistakenly be protected when they are not. Mozilla may be putting lives at risk here, and what's truly irritating, is that Mozilla's said engineering director, didn't seem to realize Mozilla could've built something that integrates with the operating systems' network stack properly.
Mozilla should've invested in improving DoH support at the OS-level or built a VPN client, again, that worked at the OS level to protect all DNS requests and/or network traffic, rather than trying to shoehorn in a way to redirect your DNS queries to their partner into your existing install.
I have nothing inherently against Cloudflare, but Cloudflare should not want to be associated with this bad hack solution to DoH, and Mozilla should rethink implementing it.
- bpt3 7y agoCan you elaborate on how performing DNS lookups over HTTPS is putting lives at risk and what significant breakage will occur with this approach? Also, I would argue that the most effective way for an organization that maintains a popular browser to impact DNS requests is at the browser level.
- muraiki 7y ago> Can you elaborate on how performing DNS lookups over HTTPS is putting lives at risk The article touches on this.
- bpt3 7y agoUnder the "DoH for oppressive regimes" section? Either way, I would welcome confirmation and/or elaboration on how DoH makes things worse than the status quo, not worse than a theoretical ideal that doesn't exist.
- rocqua 7y agoFrom his post, the argument for putting lives at risk seems to be a false sense of security for apps using the OS resolver for DNS.
- bpt3 7y agoI agree that's his implication, I was hoping for him to expand on that thought.
- Jonnax 7y agoYour tone is quite alarmist and combative. If this is how you approached them then it makes sense that you were blocked. Anyways most users use Mac and Windows not Linux. How can Mozilla fund the development of DoH on the network level? Also on Linux, dnsmasq can be configured to use DNS over HTTPS. At the end of the day. This is DNS is just looking up IP addresses in an address book.