3 ms·
How would your “better Internet” work when it reaches an ocean? Maybe this doesn’t matter to you, as someone who lives in the US and mostly access websites host
by derefr 7y ago
How would your “better Internet” work when it reaches an ocean? Maybe this doesn’t matter to you, as someone who lives in the US and mostly access websites hosted in the US; but for the majority of the world, getting access to “the Internet” is more about tapping into the millisecond-latency backbone of submarine cables, than it is about last-mile residential ISPs. Those submarine cables form a natural monopoly, there’s no escaping that. They’re utility infrastructure, like country-spanning bridges.
And the usual (optimal?) outcome for ownership of utility infrastructure, is that it gets held as a “public resource” by the government of the country or countries that built it; and then companies are contracted to manage it. From there, you end up with multilateral organizations weaving those pieces of infrastructure together in a top-down way (like shipping routes, or the postal system, or, hopefully one day, low-earth orbit.)
Which is far from an anarchosyndicalist mesh of interested companies, organizations, and individuals (ala the early Internet, or the HAM radio network), but we’ve never seen an ararchosyndicalist mesh successfully serving as a reliable/fault-tolerant backbone for any commercial endeavour so far, and I don’t know if it could.
- mwcampbell 7y agoFair enough. But let's not add into the mix a single company that spans the whole world yet is headquartered in a single country.
- IOT_Apprentice 7y agoI'm not sure how being headquartered in 2, 20 or 200 countries is going to make a difference, can you please explain? At most, those would be satellite or region offices, which in the end will report to a central HQ.
- laughinghan 7y agoI think it's extremely clear that mwcampbell is pointing to being 'headquartered in a single country' as one of the aspects they don't like about a single company having too much power. It's clear they're not advocating more headquarters for companies with too much power, they're advocating more companies each with less power.
- gzer0 7y ago> yet is headquartered in a single country. The vast majority of companies have their HQ in a single country. This is due to the base function that the HQ serves for a corporation. [0][1] [0]http://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/corporate-headquarters.asp http://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/corporate-headquarters.a... [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_headquarters#Locations_of_corporate_headquarters https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_headquarters#Locatio...
- kortilla 7y agoSubmarine cables absolutely are not a monopoly, natural or otherwise. It’s the ocean, it’s pretty fucking big, and lots of companies and countries pay more cable every day.