3 ms·
Glaciers are the charismatic megafauna of climate. They're easy to see and feel attachment to. Anybody paying attention to the science already grasps what is w
by jfengel 7y ago
Glaciers are the charismatic megafauna of climate. They're easy to see and feel attachment to.
Anybody paying attention to the science already grasps what is wrong and has at least some ideas about what to do. But an awful lot of people don't pay attention to the science -- not least because an enormous number of people deliberately obfuscate it -- and so you need other methods of persuasion.
It's easier to get people to pay attention to large, attractive animals than to concern themselves with small, ugly ones even if the latter are more crucial to the food chain. We may not "need" the Alps glaciers, but they're easier to understand than a 0.1 pH drop in the oceans, and they have the same root cause.
Among scientists it may feel dishonest to focus on truthful but not-critical aspects of climate change. Scientists were almost universally persuaded decades ago, yet action fails to come because scientists are only a tiny fraction of the population. Even a huge number of people calling for action against climate change don't really understand the science. Getting anything done, however, requires getting the attention of a majority of Americans, who produce massively-disproportionate carbon and are disproportionately likely to reject the evidence (or remain unpersuaded by it.)
So yeah, I'd rather "concentrate on saving the parts of the ecosystem" that need to be saved. I'd rather be doing a lot of things. Instead, people focus on what is possible rather than what is needed.
- blue_devil 7y agoThis is not about "picking" glaciers to save, they are probably beyond salvation by now. And that is the point. If people can't be startled by the emblematic "victims" like glaciers and polar bears, can we even hope for urgency? :/
- jfengel 7y agoI personally am really pessimistic -- cynical, even -- and you kinda don't want to hear my answer. I admire people who are trying and feel it's worth trying to understand their tactics and strategy. Of necessity that means non-rational arguments to appeal to non-rational people, so that means there might be a rationale to be learned. As I said, I doubt it. But it's just as well that somebody is trying, if that's how they wish to spend their time.
- blue_devil 7y agoYour pessimism may be due to a common human bias that occurs in coordination problems of this kind. Some call it the "drop in the ocean" effect. I hope this encourages you.