3 ms·
And I think the iterated version of the game is worse. Once you give estimate N₁, they don't like the answer and ask again. Maybe they use different words, or a
by wpietri 7y ago
And I think the iterated version of the game is worse. Once you give estimate N₁, they don't like the answer and ask again. Maybe they use different words, or ask different people, or make small changes. Maybe they just imply it seems high. So now we have N₂ < N₁. Repeat until the manager is happy with Nₓ.
Nₓ is of course is about 1 day past the "absolutely impossible" time. So now we have gone from 50% likely to hit the date to 5% or less. So at best we get yelled at for being "late" to a number that was about what the manager wanted, not reality. Or worse, we finish the visible work on the day of, while leaving a lot of hidden work (e.g., technical debt) for the future, increasing the size and volatility of future estimates.
And that's not even mentioning that all of the conditions of the original estimate (e.g., scope won't change) are breezily ignored even when the date is remembered.
It's a stupid game, and I've stopped playing it.
- RussianCow 7y ago> It's a stupid game, and I've stopped playing it. Care to share the secret of how you did that? :)
- wpietri 7y agoBasically instead of giving them a sense of control, it's to give them actual control. What I promise to do is release a new version of whatever they want at least once a week, and hopefully more often. If every week (or every day) they get to decide what that is, they stop caring about estimates. More here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21071374 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21071374 And I also wrote something up in response to a previous HN discussion: http://williampietri.com/writing/2014/simple-planning-for-startups/ http://williampietri.com/writing/2014/simple-planning-for-st...