11 ms·
Oh yeah : - Before Snowden, if you spoke about these issues, you were dismissed as paranoid. - After Snowden, if you dismiss these issues, you are dismissed a
by BlueTemplar 7y ago
Oh yeah :
- Before Snowden, if you spoke about these issues, you were dismissed as paranoid.
- After Snowden, if you dismiss these issues, you are dismissed as hopelessly naive...
Oh, also - considering all this - you can bet that Intel's Management Engine has likely been backdoored by the NSA, so using Intel's processors is not recommended, especially if you're a non-US company... (industrial espionage !)
https://blog.invisiblethings.org/papers/2015/x86_harmful.pdf https://blog.invisiblethings.org/papers/2015/x86_harmful.pdf
- Hendrikto 7y ago> Before Snowden, if you spoke about these issues, you were dismissed as paranoid. I’ve been telling people for years, but nobody listened. Now everyone knows it’s true, but still nobody seems to care…
- stiray 7y agoDescription of my life. I was telling people for years what is going on, not from position of daydreaming, but what I would be able to pull off. I got back everything from tin foil hat to "I have nothing to hide". Snowden changed that and I am gratefull to him for exactly that... And for one more sentance, that is a work of pure genius: “Arguing that you don't care about the right to privacy because you have nothing to hide is no different than saying you don't care about free speech because you have nothing to say.” <3 And how the world is changing, from GDPR to California privacy law... I would just love to shake hand to this guy.
- Darkstryder 7y ago> “Arguing that you don't care about the right to privacy because you have nothing to hide is no different than saying you don't care about free speech because you have nothing to say.” I find this sentence interesting because it is very specific to the American public. I am European and personally I care a lot more about privacy than free speech, and America's obsession with free speech boggles my mind. It might have to do with the last time we in Europe experimented with unadulterated free speech, and got Hitler and WW2 as a result. We might have dialed it back a bit after that. But what do I know ? There seems to be some a profound divide between America and Europe on this front and I haven't quite put my finger on why yet.
- stiray 7y agoI am European too. But without the freedom of speech, we wouldnt be discussing this. They are both liberties and we need them both. There is no "I care more about X". We need them both as fundamental human rights.
- Darkstryder 7y agoOf course. But free speech is not absolute, even in USA (libel laws and all that). What I find interesting is how the threshold between the freedom of speech and the freedom of others people is set differently between US and most of Europe. For instance you can be convicted for incitement to ethnic or racial hatred in a lot of European countries [1] while to the best of my knowledge this kind of speech is protected in the US. Personally I am very happy with how the free speech threshold is set in France or Germany but I have no doubt it is a cultural thing. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incitement_to_ethnic_or_racial_hatred https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incitement_to_ethnic_or_racial...
- homonculus1 7y agoWho defines incitement? Who defines ethnic or racial hatred? Is it incitement of racial hatred to post a joke video of your dog performing a Nazi salute?
- Darkstryder 7y agoEvery country's law is a bit different in that regard, but mostly : exactly like how the United States Supreme Court defines obscenity [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_know_it_when_I_see_it https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_know_it_when_I_see_it
- lostjohnny 7y ago> Is it incitement of racial hatred to post a joke video of your dog performing a Nazi salute? Why did you post it? Because you know it's controversial and would create engagement. If the nazi salute wasn't controversial (and rightfully considered hate crime) you would have ignored it. BTW the first amendment does not condone hate speech. Because even USA understands that there is a limit on everything.
- BlueTemplar 7y agoI was actually more positive than reality, for a better "quip" - I still had a discussion where the other person pushed the "I have nothing to hide" angle as recently as last month ! And that persons' grandparents died in Auschwitz... (Thankfully, this seems to be much more rare in the "tech" circles ?)
- BuildTheRobots 7y agoThe "I've got nothing to hide" angle terrifies me. As one obvious example, LGBT Russians had absolutely nothing to hide, right up until the moment it was outlawed, again. Then suddenly it was extremely easy to identify and persecute. In a world where we hold people like Willem Arondeus, Sophie Scholl or anyone else involved in hiding or exfiltrating Jews during WW2 a hero, it baffles me that the idea of "nothing to hide" even exists. The fact we've made a modern kinder-transport or even a resistance nearly technologically impossible honestly stops me sleeping.
- nine_k 7y agoCertain Richard M Stallman faced a similar problem when he talked about DRMed content a decade ago.
- 693471 7y agoEven a broken clock is correct twice a day
- lixtra 7y agoMore like two decades ago. https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.en.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.en.html
- BlueTemplar 7y agoOh, yeah, that too - for me, after Snowden, Stallman went from "crank"-ey to "prophet"-ey ! (Well, and GAFAM's behavior in the recent years certainly didn't help either...) P.S.: Got Stallman to sign my The Snowden Files book after he introduced his speech with asking the public to give "three cheers for Snowden"...
- appleshore 7y agoIf I asked 10 people around me, who is Edward Snowden, maybe one would know. When the story broke, I never heard anyone in real life bring it up. I know young wealthy people who don’t know who Elon Musk is. People’s attention is highly fragmented.
- cookie_monsta 7y agoIt's not about the guy's name, what's important is how people's perceptions have changed (which I would generalise as from scornful dismissal to resigned acceptance)
- atoav 7y agoIsn’t it a bit like global warming? If people feel the issue is so much bigger than them they will just resign and give up. Unless you communicate why we need to do sth anyways and what small managable steps can be taken it is hard to tackle this alone, even if you are an informed person with the motivation and the breathing space to do so. So unless the felt pain and the impeding doom doesn’t exceed the threshold of “oh shit this isn’t fine, what was I thinking!” people will just call the whole thing off as unmanagable and move ahead.
- PopeDotNinja 7y agoI wouldn't say I don't care. I would say I permanently trust government less, as I do feel mostly powerless to make them less nosey. If I have an opportunity to vote against mass surveillance, I will do that for sure.
- cookie_monsta 7y agoUnder what circumstances can you imagine being given a vote on mass surveillance?
- PopeDotNinja 7y agoNot many.
- Fnoord 7y agoIn The Netherlands, we had a non-binding referendum on this [1] (complete with misinformation, or downright propaganda, on TV). The vote against had a minor but significant win on the for. Result? 1) The law got active a few months later 2) A few minor changes were applied 3) The right for a non-binding referendum got removed from The Netherlands, citing we should either have a binding referendum or none at all. [1] https://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wet_op_de_inlichtingen-_en_veiligheidsdiensten_2017 https://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wet_op_de_inlichtingen-_en_vei... (article also available in German and Chinese)
- cookie_monsta 7y agoInteresting, but I guess that considering that the govt. announced their intention to pass the law regardless of the result of the referendum my question should have been "under what circumstances can you imagine being given a _meaningful_ vote on mass surveillance?"
- Fnoord 7y agoYou can't. A democracy, and a binding referendum, stands on the shoulder of the public being informed and interested about matters. The public does not know enough about the topic. They can't, because the enemy listens as well in this global world. Hence, the proponents can pull FUD and appeal to authority at will. I'm a proponent of binding referendum, but I don't see how it would solve the problem in this case.
- throwaway_law 7y ago>Now everyone knows it’s true, but still nobody seems to care… That just about sums up every bad act. Lots of people were aware of all the bank fraud and toxic loans leading to the 2008 real estate bubble, no one cared leading up to it, and no one cares now. The Googles/Facebooks/amazons are collecting and doing unsavory things with your data, whether you ever used their services or not (shadow accounts), no one seems to care. Governmental spying on citizens? Hell the Government had a program which included secret kill lists, flew military bombers into foreign countries to drop bombs and kill a citizen. Even when the US failed to kill the citizen and the family sued, their case was dismissed as the courts denied any right to know who was on the list, how they got on the list, and even denied acknowledging the list existed...yet no one cared. Imagine a foreign country flying military missions in the US and dropping bombs on a foreigner in the US, based on the foreign governments secret kill lists. It's pure insanity.
- hokumguru 7y agoSource on this?
- NegativeLatency 7y agohttps://www.nytimes.com/2012/05/29/world/obamas-leadership-in-war-on-al-qaeda.html https://www.nytimes.com/2012/05/29/world/obamas-leadership-i... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disposition_Matrix https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disposition_Matrix
- Fnoord 7y agoNational Bird [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Bird_(film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Bird_(film)
- harryf 7y agoWell it might have contributed to GDPR, which is a step in the right direction.
- BlueTemplar 7y agoWell, it's pretty much a situation of war. And an unconventional war against terrorists. (Also, not unprecedented - the Russians have been doing something very similar in a few high-profile UK cases...) Of course, the main issue is that those "surgical" drone strikes still seem to have backfired strategically - I wonder what is the state of these "who are we going to kill today" reunions under Trump ? And of course in the background there's the whole Middle Eastern situation where the USA (and previously the British Empire) have only been making things worse for a century or so... but the control over those oil fields is just too important for them to let go !
- chiefalchemist 7y ago> "Now everyone knows it’s true, but still nobody seems to care… " In general, the mainstream media didn't make much of it. At the time they hadn't yet tied outrage to revenue/profits. If Snowden were to happen today the coverage and reaction would be much different. But alas, it's too late. The public has it in their minds it was a non-issue. That seems unlikely to change any time soon.
- wefarrell 7y agoInformation sharing is like entropy - it will only increase over time. We're moving towards a future where privacy is becoming an archaic concept.
- nickpsecurity 7y agoYeah, he's wrong that the most paranoid weren't assuming how bad it was. If anything, Enemy of the State had general public worried with Echelon revelations and technical details of Puzzle Palace making me certain they were doing mass surveillance and hacking. At least within a few years of 9/11 and Patriot Act. They'd do whatever they (a) could and (b) had to do for their mission. Far as weakening, we were noting they did a lot of things that were public knowledge that indicated they prioritized shoddy products and surveillance over security. I had an essay listing most of them. I might dig it up and submit it Thursday if anyone is interested.
- Fnoord 7y agoI remember people in infosec and *NIX communities being paranoid about the NSA back in the early '00s. Americans who were not trusting their own government. I myself only heard about the CIA and FBI. I familiarized myself with the concept of NSA and shrugged it off. "Never hear anything about those. Probably a very small organization..." In hindsight, I was right, but I didn't get with the program after 9/11 (see the accounts of William Binney [1] and Edward Snowden's recently Permanent Record). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Binney_(intelligence_official) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Binney_(intelligence_o...
- lawnchair_larry 7y agoThere is nothing to suggest an ME backdoor. I’d call it unlikely.
- bonerman69 7y agoLol
- IHLayman 7y agoWatch this Blackhat 2017 talk and maybe it'll change your mind: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KrksBdWcZgQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KrksBdWcZgQ
- lawnchair_larry 7y agoVery familiar with it, nothing indicating a backdoor there.
- gamegod 7y agoYeah, we'll just go ahead and use x86 processors from AMD, another US company, which are surely not backdoored...
- BlueTemplar 7y agoAFAIK, the equivalent of IME is not present in all AMD processors, only (maybe) those with integrated graphic chips ? But overall, yeah, Europe should just create their own chip industry, it's too critical to leave it to others...
- noir_lord 7y agoIronically enough we (the UK) actually had a massive input in the current chip landscape via ARM until the government allowed it to be sold to a foreign buyer. You have to wonder if the French government would have allowed the sale (as an example). Seems like the conservatives don't give a shit about strategic national companies as long as the cheques clear.
- BlueTemplar 7y agoAre you aware that the French government allowed the sale of the maker of turbines for their nuclear submarines, aircraft carrier, and reactors ?
- repolfx 7y agoARM doesn't make CPUs, just designs for them which can of course easily be modified by any licensee. The chips themselves are usually made in Asia. So ARMs ownership is irrelevant to the issue of CPU back doors.
- nullc 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AMD_Platform_Security_Processor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AMD_Platform_Security_Processo...
- BlueTemplar 7y ago
- pingyong 7y ago>https://blog.invisiblethings.org/papers/2015/x86_harmful.pdf https://blog.invisiblethings.org/papers/2015/x86_harmful.pdf The author dismisses CPU-level backdoors in favor of Intel ME backdoors mainly on the basis that, since CPUs can't save state, they can't protect themselves against replay-"attacks", and hence Intel would lose any sort of plausible deniability once an "activation sequence" was ever found in the wild. But I don't really see how ME is protected against replay-"attacks" either. Sure, you might not be able to replay the sequence to the same CPU, but you can definitely replay it to a different CPU - unless every single CPU out there has a different activation sequence, which is possible, but would be vastly less efficient (if you want to hack someone you now have to know / guess some sort of unique production ID of the CPUs he's using?). I'm really not seeing the big argument in favor of an ME backdoor here. A backdoor directly in the CPU would work just as well. Arguably better in fact, since the CPU can just look for the activation sequence in the data it reads (if you send an e-mail or website it's very likely the plaintext string gets copied, and therefore read, by the CPU at some point), whereas the ME processor would only be able to watch specific offsets in memory.
- jigglesniggle 7y agoYou assume a device can not be tracked from creation to dsitribution. Why?
- throwaway2048 7y agosupply chain tracking is extremely difficult even for entire ecosystems that make it their near maximum priority (such as say, military procurement). There isn't a hope in hell you can reliably keep track of who has which Intel CPU. Think of all the stages involved, and how each one has to cooperate and how many times Intel's CPU is sitting on "undifferentiated palette of X units".
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- pingyong 7y ago
- mc32 7y agoOne of the most interesting revelations was the security agencies apparent spying on members of Congress. But it’s like nothing happened. No investigation, no nothing. If they can’t be bothered by that, it’s little surprise they’re not bothered by their spying on regular folk.
- java-man 7y agoThat should tell us who is really in charge.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoYes, the American people, who can't be bothered to care enough to do anything about it.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bediger4000 7y agoGoogle "jane harman alberto gonzales". George W. Bush's Attorney General was apparently "twisting Rep. Jane Harman's arm" over some moderately bad things that FBI or somebody caught Harman saying to some AIPAC people being surveilled. That was in 2009. I remember being kind of stunned that nobody seemed to care that the executive branch blackmailed an elected Rep. Log rolling and pork barrelling is fine, but blackmail seems like a bridge too far.
- djsumdog 7y agoToday, if you suggest that Snowden is a plant; how he might still be working for a government agency like the NSA, CIA or State Department; how he was a black ops to see how Americans would react: you get dismissed as paranoid. Every time I bring this up, I get downvoted to grey. Can we have an honest discussion on this? Guy makes six figured, works remotely as an NSA contractor from Hawaii, suddenly had a moral conscience, somehow had multiple laptops with classified data, leaves his smoking hot girlfriend to meet journalists from The Guardian and Der Spegiel and gave them evidence that was composed of poorly made slides; almost all of which have been released heavily redacted -- all have been heavily dismissed by the US government, Yahoo, Google, Verizon and others. Honestly, the 9/11 truth evidence feels like it should have been more convincing, and yet every media agency took this as gospel. If the revelations are taken at face value, why couldn't it also be possible this was all just a test by intelligence agencies? Companies have strengthened their general security and the general population hasn't .. really cared. Both of those are valuable pieces of information gathered by the government. Look at COINTELPRO and Operation Mockingbird. At the time, if you had said such programs existed, it would have been viewed as crazy conspiracy. But they did exist and intelligence agencies in the US government has manipulated their own people in past decades. Either Snowden is incredibly clever and lucky, or he's a stage show. He should be in the situation Assange is in now. It's difficult to believe he's still in an unknown location, hiding out in Russia. The whole story stinks and I feel like no one wants to have a rational talk about the alternative: that it may be more manipulation and testing to show that Americans don't really care about surveillance.
- trenning 7y agoIf the govt wanted to test the public's reaction I don't think they needed to go so far as to reveal PRISM or MUSCULAR. > It's difficult to believe he's still in an unknown location, hiding out in Russia. Wouldn't this make Russia a party to this theory? As far as I can tell they don't deny harboring Snowden, which if he wasn't actually there hiding from the USG wouldn't they call the US on that?
- rocqua 7y agoI haven't followed this closely, but how much of what Snowned revealed has since been independently confirmed?
- biggt 7y agoMe_cleaner might help with Intel's backdoor management engine
- IanSanders 7y agoI wonder if all this recent bad intel publicity could be in response to me_cleaner actually making it more secure.