6 ms·
Hey, not too bad, at least for nuclear. If you look back at the history of nuclear construction, at least in the US, late and massively over budget is the norm
by epistasis 7y ago
Hey, not too bad, at least for nuclear.
If you look back at the history of nuclear construction, at least in the US, late and massively over budget is the norm. Late and over budget are closely tied together, of course, as it's all about project management and that's not trivial at this scale. This sort of typical overrun is why US utilities stopped building more nuclear in the 80s.
- LiamMcCalloway 7y agoIn the 70s.
- kryogen1c 7y ago> This sort of typical overrun is why US utilities stopped building more nuclear in the 80s. Thats some revisionist history to fit the current zeitgeist, right there. What stopped nuclear construction in the United States was the complete overreaction to Three Mile Island and the disaster at Chernobyl
- LiamMcCalloway 7y agoNo new decisions to build nuclear 10 years prior to three mile island.
- thrillgore 7y agoFalse. In 2007 construction on Watts Bar unit 2 resumed after years of waiting. Similar work began on Vogtle around the same time. Stop blaming Chernobyl when the truth is clear: the costs of retrofitting most reactor designs to absolve fault tolerance make them inherent unprofitable compared to wind, geothermal, and solar.
- pfdietz 7y agoNuclear had started running off the rails as early as 1968. TMI was just the cherry on top of the financial crap sundae. http://ansnuclearcafe.org/2016/02/16/nuclear-plant-cost-escalation-a-look-back-and-ahead/ http://ansnuclearcafe.org/2016/02/16/nuclear-plant-cost-esca... The major regulatory hit that that first wave of US nuclear plants took wasn't specific to nuclear: the Calvert Cliffs decision held that the National Environmental Policy Act applied broadly, including to the regulatory process of the AEC. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calvert_Cliffs_Coordinating_Committee,_Inc._v._Atomic_Energy_Commission https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calvert_Cliffs_Coordinating_Co...
- kryogen1c 7y agoBoy do i appear to be wrong. This was not my underatanding at all. As you and siblings pointed out, nuclear seems to have been frought with problems for a long time. Wikipedia, if it is to be believed, paints an even more dire picture than you say: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_the_United_States https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_the_United_... I find this so counterintuitive having safely operated naval nuclear reactors. More research is needed from me!
- manfredo 7y agoYour comment above was not entirely wrong. The majority of nuclear energy's costs are overhead costs of plant construction. If a plant is not operated for its intended service life, $/MWH will skyrocket. Opposition to nuclear power (which existed prior to Three Mile Island, and increased thereafter) caused plants to be closed prematurely. This drove up the effective cost of nuclear energy, fueling the push for more closures on the basis of higher costs, and so on. Curiously, these sorts of high nuclear costs are not experienced by every country. France's electricity (70-80% nuclear) is a fraction of the cost of Germany's electricity production, while simultaneously emitting less carbon. Countries like South Korea, and Japan (until they cancelled nuclear plants following the tsunami) had cost effective nuclear industries. Cost overruns happened, but not as large as compared to the US. The main explanations for this that I have encountered is that US nuclear plants have tended to be one-off projects, whereas other countries implemented serialized production of a handful of designs. Building 10 instances of the same plant is easier than building 10 different plants.
- pfdietz 7y agoGermany decided, as an act of global charity, to buy renewables when they were much more expensive (they were the top global market for PV ten years ago, when PV was far more expensive than it is now), to drive them down their learning curves. This was spectacularly successful, but they are still paying for that. It says nothing about what someone else would have to pay NOW to install the same renewable capacity. At the same time, France has tried to get its nuclear industry going again with new reactors, to disastrous result. So if you want to build energy infrastructure in 1980, sure, go ahead and choose nuclear over renewables. If you want to do it now, that choice would be crazy.
- epistasis 7y agoAbsolutely not, the history and timelines do not support the narrative of TMI and Chernobyl stopping construction. They certainly didn't help, but go back and read this pre-Chernobyl analysis that lays the blame squarely on mismanagement: https://blowhardwindbag.blogspot.com/2011/04/forbes-article-reference-nuclear.html?m=1 https://blowhardwindbag.blogspot.com/2011/04/forbes-article-... Or look at when new projects were started, and you see nuclear starts dramatically fall even before we had TMI and Chernobyl. The revisionist history is to say that we stopped building nuclear because we are scared of it. The reality is that economics and bad management make it extremely unattractive to build, then and now.
- vermontdevil 7y agoThere’s one being built right now in Georgia. Vogtle Power Station. Yup you guessed it. Over budget and late. Though to be fair - I think the timeline was too aggressive when it was first proposed. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vogtle_Electric_Generating_Plant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vogtle_Electric_Generating_Pla... Another utility canceled a project that was underway in South Carolina.
- barry-cotter 7y agoOver budget and late is the norm for projects that complicated. If you’re spending enormous sums of money on something that isn’t very, very close to something you know how to do, again you’ve actually done something very similar, and recently, massive cost overruns are the norm[1]. If the average software project is over budget, late and doesn’t do all the things it was supposed to do on design stage, just think how much more complex these things are. [1]https://arxiv.org/pdf/1409.0003.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1409.0003.pdf
- pfdietz 7y agoWind and PV projects typically come in within 10% of estimates.