5 ms·
> Company Vice President and Treasurer Douglas Patterson thought it would be a clever idea to use the actual SSN of his secretary, Mrs. Hilda Schrader Whitcher.
by jchw 7y ago
> Company Vice President and Treasurer Douglas Patterson thought it would be a clever idea to use the actual SSN of his secretary, Mrs. Hilda Schrader Whitcher.
Can someone explain why this would be “clever?” It just sounds like a bad idea to me.
- little_airport 7y agoI think they were being sarcastic.
- jchw 7y agoI get this, but I mean, they did actually do it, so apparently the idea didn’t set off any alarm bells in their head. I guess it must’ve just not been well thought out.
- mirimir 7y agoThis was in 1938. Just three years after the Social Security Administration had been created. Most people still had telephone party lines. People didn't get how some government number could be really important.
- klaustopher 7y agoAlso, at that point it was not this global number that was used to identify you everywhere. It was your registration number in the Social Security system, not more. Well, you could use it to pay into somebody else‘s pension ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Aomebody linked a CGP Grey video above that goes into details.
- maitredusoi 7y agoYou are thinking with a 2019 point of view, this was effectivly 1938, people were less aware of consequences of their actions (as history of that dark period shown accross the World ...). Also,probably at that time people thought that a real SSN would shine more than 000-00-0000, as any other number could potentially be a "real" number from an unkown person ...
- qubex 7y agoI think it was construed as being ’clever’ in the same sense as inserting an Easter Egg or veiled reference to obscure pop culture is today. So that would make it a Mad Men-era <nod> <nod> <wink> <wink> Easter Egg from more innocent times before identity theft was even remotely conceived of (and before executives learnt the hard way to need to assume that the world is populated by imbeciles).
- Pinckney 7y agoThe SSN was never intended to be a secret. Nobody in 1938 thought that one day banks and other businesses would use it as a credential to establish identity.
- masklinn 7y agoSSCs even used to have "not for identification" stamped on them before SSA gave up (the note was there from '46 to '72).
- sverige 7y agoMy circa 1969 SSC has that printed on it. For GP, actually yes, people did think it would be used as a credential to establish identity, and many feared (correctly, as it turns out) that would happen. The phrase used by those people was "Papers, please!" with a German accent, since it was well known by the mid-40s that identity papers were used by the Nazis to control the population. Later variations by people my age was to use a Russian accent since the Bolsheviks also used papers to control the population. My uncle and aunt never had SSNs for that reason (and no, never paid into or collected social security either.) I have a friend who is now in his late 50s who has never given his SSN to anyone except the IRS and his employer -- which is actually the law, or at least used to be, perhaps it has changed. Rather than assume older people are less privacy conscious, the correct assumption is that younger people are less inclined to protect their privacy. Many millennials don't even believe in privacy. I blame it on the generally poor education in history that most younger people have received.
- davchana 7y agoI was renting an apartment few weeks ago, & If I had refused to not give SSN, tough luck, application will not move forward.
- nihilist_t21 7y agoIf it was a law, it has since changed. The IRS has the W-9 form specifically for the requesting of an SSN (or EIN if a company). At my job I require it before issuing a non-employment related payment that will get reported to the IRS on a 1099-MISC.
- aptwebapps 7y agoThe clever part was using his secretary's instead of his own.
- 7952 7y agoIt is possible that people were not used to carrying cards around, and didn't know what the pocket was for.