6 ms·
The problem is that it is reasonable to expel people (and, indeed, to want to expel people) with a much much lower burden of proof than would be required to loc
by sneak 7y ago
The problem is that it is reasonable to expel people (and, indeed, to want to expel people) with a much much lower burden of proof than would be required to lock them in a cage.
There absolutely should be a different standard for “can continue to be in this school”
and “can continue to walk down the public sidewalk”, and also decided by different people.
- mieseratte 7y agoWhy should they have a lower burden of proof?
- jayd16 7y agoFor starters its a civil vs criminal distinction.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoThe government is imposing penalties for criminal behavior. Classifying that as "civil" is a farce.
- throwaway2048 7y agoYou can be sued in civil court for criminal actions.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoYou can be sued in civil court for money. You're not held in prison or kicked out of school by government fiat in the meantime. And the damages (if any) are imposed after the court proceeding. The exceptions are related to things like civil asset forfeiture, which are of questionable constitutionality and are similar to the rules we're discussing insofar as they are both worthy of contempt.
- throwaway2048 7y agoA university tribunal is not government fiat, and a civil court has more power than simply issuing fines.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoA university tribunal that operates as a result of federal requirements is government fiat, and a civil court is primarily concerned with awarding damages rather than imposing penalties. That they sometimes do other things is evidence more that the legal system is messy and flawed than that the exceptions should be the rule.
- throwaway2048 7y agoIts an investigative process with procedure and hearings, its no more a fiat than a court is.
- caseysoftware 7y agoExcept - as noted in article - none of the people involved are trained investigators, the starting position it to believe accusers (instead of being impartial), the accused are not allowed legal representation, and they're often under a tribunal-imposed gag order. There is nothing "just" in that situation. The protections afforded to both the accused and the accuser are to provide safeguards for everyone involved.
- jayd16 7y agoIt would be ridiculous to have every school policy passed by state and local legislation. That power is delegated to academic reagents. Because it's not a law, it can't be ruled on in court. Because it can't be ruled on, they use this form of arbitration to solve what would be a civil matter if the school was a private entity. Its not nearly as unreasonable as you make it seem.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> It would be ridiculous to have every school policy passed by state and local legislation. That power is delegated to academic reagents. The point in this case is that it isn't. Both the policy and the procedural rules are imposed by federal requirements. If it was actually a policy of the school then it would be non-uniform and students could avoid schools with unreasonable policies, or push for changes to the local policy that are more achievable than it is for an individual to change federal policy.
- drewrv 7y agoBecause attending Harvard is a privilege, walking down a public sidewalk is a right.
- Sophistifunk 7y agoNo, it's not. "Sneak was expelled from harvard for raping somebody" is not something you want people reading without getting your day in court.
- sneak 7y agoWell, you just wrote that and people are reading it and I seem to have no recourse as you describe. Which is it exactly that you are advocating for?
- mc32 7y agoAt the same time someone’s standing shouldn’t be in danger due to a malicious accusation. This is a really hard problem because you want victims to be helped and not have to go through a grueling process for something they didn’t bring upon themselves, but simultaneously you don’t want to enable false accusations which would put undue burden on someone who didn’t bring that upon themselves either.
- aidenn0 7y agoA malicious accusation always puts ones standing in danger. If I were to accuse you of just about any crime, your odds of being wrongfully convicted of that crime go up, even if just a little. If I get this claim published widely enough, you will have a harder time finding a job, even if it the claim later proven false. The question at hand is whether or not things have gone too far.
- mc32 7y agoAgree. With social media it’s amplified and even opinions can have detrimental effects on people’s standing. Asking whether it has gone too far is like asking if someone died too much. This problem currently has no good solution -barring a true “lie detector”, but even that is insufficient because people can believe things that didn’t happen as they recall, etc., you’d need something more like a “reconstruct the scenario do we the jury can interpret”
- nwallin 7y ago> The question at hand is whether or not things have gone too far. I think it's fairly clear that it has, at this point. 1. Sexual assault is defined so broadly it's virtually impossible to legal have sex. "Can I hug you?" "Yes" "Can I kiss you?" "Yes" "Can I squeeze your butt?" "Yes" etc. Did you kiss their neck without asking for and receiving positive, enthusiastic consent? That's sexual assault. 2. There's no recourse if there's an accusation. Notification of a complaint is stated in the form of expulsion. Once expelled, there's no appeals process. There can and should be an extra judicial system to expect offenders. But this is the wrong one.
- denkmoon 7y agoI guess it's a good thing that the judicial system is able to deliver many different kinds of judgement rather than just locking people in a cage, then.
- BurningFrog 7y agoI can see expelling people for things that are not crimes, such as cheating on tests, or breaking any number of arbitrary rules But having a lower standard of proof means expelling people who haven't actually done what you're expelling them for. That's a whole other thing, and I'm very hesitant about it. Of course, when the expulsions almost only happen to members of one gender, on the say-so of members of the other gender, it gets extra complicated.
- claudiawerner 7y agoThere's a great paper on this, Rape Culture and Epistemology[0] which, although provocatively titled, addresses why a lower standard of proof may be appropriate. >We’ll argue that this sort of deference is mistaken, for at least two kinds of reasons. One is that, as anti-rape activists have often emphasized, law enforcement procedures themselves are deeply flawed when it comes to their practice of dealing with sexual assault. Another has to do with the connections between knowledge and action, and between knowledge and knowledge ascriptions. We also think that these disparate considerations are more closely interconnected than it may at first appear. [0] https://philarchive.org/archive/CRERCA-2 https://philarchive.org/archive/CRERCA-2
- naasking 7y ago> We’ll argue that this sort of deference is mistaken, for at least two kinds of reasons. One is that, as anti-rape activists have often emphasized, law enforcement procedures themselves are deeply flawed when it comes to their practice of dealing with sexual assault. Totally agreed. That doesn't justify instituting another unjust system to somehow counterbalance the existing unjust system. This just shifts the injustice to another class of people, it doesn't eliminate it, and human nature being what it is, people will exploit it for selfish ends. You can only eliminate injustice by specifically addressing the injustice, not by moving it around.
- claudiawerner 7y agoThe presumption in your comment is that the system that replaces the legal system in these situations is equally or more unjust - however according to the authors, by realizing why the legal system is unjust, a university body may do a better job - after all, it is undoubtedly easier to change the laws of a university body than to change them in society as a whole, and the university body may not subject to the same cultural pressures the state is (according to the authors, this would be a patriarchal culture).