5 ms·
So far, the comments here are seriously misunderstanding what Amazon is doing here, and are getting unnecessarily inflammatory just because it’s Big Bad Amazon.
by dangus 7y ago
So far, the comments here are seriously misunderstanding what Amazon is doing here, and are getting unnecessarily inflammatory just because it’s Big Bad Amazon.
It’s just a remote care benefit. My current employer offers it, administered by a vendor, and it’s separate from your actual insurance. You can call or video chat, send pictures, and even get prescriptions filled off-hours. It comes in handy for a lot of common quick scenarios.
The only news is that Amazon is big enough to self administer it.
It’s pretty much inevitable that companies of that immense size save money by self-administering or self-insuring many benefits like this.
- chiefalchemist 7y ago> "The only news is that Amazon is big enough to self administer it." But now there's no protective layer between the employee, their personal data trail and the employer. I would suspect that for some diseases / consitions this situation is going to discourage employees to seek care.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tempsy 7y agoI don’t think anyone is disagreeing with you. The “inflammatory” comments reach the same conclusion, that telemedicine is a cost saving tactic to save money, which is true. I think this just serve as another reason why employer-based healthcare insurance is a weird anomaly that should be done away with. If you work at a large company then your health plan will almost certainly be self-insured, and now not only are you a worker for said company you’re now this risk that is being watched and managed by your company that knows every healthcare interaction you have. It’s creepy.
- xeromal 7y agoIf you read comments on reddit and hackernews, a lot of people seem dead set on avoiding social contact when possible. The service solves that problem somewhat. You don't have to leave home or work to get treated, so in a way, this might encourage people to take care of themselves more.
- ehPReth 7y agopeople are scary :( if only i lived in appland, canada where the apps roamed free (aka some major city)
- xeromal 7y agoOh me too, lol. I like getting out. I'm just saying the appeal of a remote service might be beyond people like us.
- pvaldes 7y agoAnd, with the antibiotic-resistent bacteria, go to an hospital includes some probability of catching a live-threatening secondary infection. This can be dangerous for fragile people and elders. If the nature of their illness allow them to be treated at distance in their home that could make a difference. Can't be done for all cases and sceneries of course.
- draw_down 7y agoI think people can have a problem with something amazon does without them being petulant and inflammatory. Not everything Amazon does is great.
- arcticbull 7y agoMuch as I think this is a job for the state and not private sector, America has a long history of employers providing healthcare. Kaiser started out as a shipbuilding company with in-house medical clinic, and eventually the shipbuilding arm folded and the medical arm opened up to all comers, yielding today’s KP. What’s old is new again, as they say.
- doctorpangloss 7y agoWithout judging the quality of Kaiser's care, consider that it makes about as much sense that a shipbuilding company is now a healthcare insurer as the fact that General Electric was a finance firm. This is the root of the newsworthiness of Amazon's entries into new businesses.
- tonyhb 7y agoTo judge the quality of Kaiser's care, they're best in class. Several studies and reports show that Kaiser delivers some of the best care you can get. (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3383159/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3383159/, https://www.bmj.com/content/324/7330/135.short https://www.bmj.com/content/324/7330/135.short, https://about.kaiserpermanente.org/our-story/news/accolades-and-awards/kaiser-permanente-earns-californias-highest-ratings-clinical-car https://about.kaiserpermanente.org/our-story/news/accolades-..., https://www.healthaffairs.org/doi/pdf/10.1377/hlthaff.19.2.185 https://www.healthaffairs.org/doi/pdf/10.1377/hlthaff.19.2.1...)
- azernik 7y agoA note for the healthcare shopper - I can testify firsthand and from doctor friends that their general healthcare is spectacular, but their mental healthcare system is in crisis. The state has repeatedly fined them for failing to provide "timely access" to mental health care (https://californiahealthline.org/news/kaiser-permanente-cited-again-for-mental-health-access-problems/ https://californiahealthline.org/news/kaiser-permanente-cite...), and their mental health care workers are going on strike not for better pay/benefits but for higher staffing and shorter patient wait times (https://www.peoplesworld.org/article/california-kaiser-mental-health-clinicians-in-fight-for-patient-care/ https://www.peoplesworld.org/article/california-kaiser-menta...).
- TrainedMonkey 7y agoYou don't think Amazon is using internal workforce to collect data before launching this on a wider scale?
- kiliantics 7y agoI read an article ~6 months ago speculating exactly this and citing internal rumours
- kerkeslager 7y agoThe problem is that there's numerous conflicts of interests and a strong possibility for abuse. A lot of people on HN seem to have an "assume everything is okay until there is insurmountable evidence that it has been catastrophically wrong for a long time" approach to regulating corporations. Historically this approach has allowed corporations to abuse workers, customers, the environment, and whoever/whatever else is profitable to abuse. Amazon isn't some ethical outlier of a corporation: they have plenty of ongoing history of worker abuses and leveraging their power in one sector to gain unfair advantage in another. So why would this be any different? So no, I don't think people are misunderstanding this, I think they're approaching what Amazon is doing with an appropriate level of skepticism. It's incredibly naive to assume that Amazon is only going to use this in the positive ways outlined in their press releases.
- TomMarius 7y agoWhat exactly changes for a person when they still have their medical insurance just like before? How can they be abused?
- kerkeslager 7y ago1. Some health insurance companies offer similar services, and Amazon has all the same perverse incentives to direct you toward cheaper treatments over more effective ones. When the entity providing healthcare is the same as the entity paying for it, there's a conflict of interest. I'm putting this first because it's already happening at health insurance companies, so it's practically guaranteed that it will happen at Amazon. 2. Amazon can leverage this to guide healthcare providers and employees toward treatments which benefit Amazon rather than the patient. A simple example would be favoring outpatient treatments which allow the employee to keep working rather than inpatient treatments which don't, regardless of which is actually the appropriate treatment. They don't have to explicitly instruct doctors to do this, they merely have to fund outpatient more, make it more prominent in their internal documents, and create more paperwork hoops for people to jump through to get inpatient treatment. Similarly, they can try to steer women away from pregnancy (and therefore maternity leave) by overstating the dangers of pregnancy, and overfunding tests which are likely to create concerns. 3. Medical providers are legally unable to share most medical data with your employer. This becomes effectively unenforceable when your medical provider is your employer. This information can be used in ways that harms workers, such as terminating employees with costly medical conditions, conditions which might cause them to miss work, mental health issues, or conditions with a social stigma such as AIDS or alcoholism. Before you say, "they can just use their healthcare through their medical insurance like before for things they don't want their employer to know about", consider that people frequently don't understand privacy, and don't understand that this information could be used to harm them, so many people won't do this. People commonly make the mistake of assuming amoral corporations will behave ethically. Privacy, especially medical privacy, should be default-on.
- Xelbair 7y ago>The only news is that Amazon is big enough to self administer it. Isn't this the crux of the issue? there is a huge conflict of interest going on here.
- VvR-Ox 7y agoExactly. Can't believe we are already beyond noticing that -.-