2 ms·
> What exactly should a journalist do then? First of all, ideally you'll leave those topics for your journalist buddies that actually know what they write abou
by luckylion 7y ago
> What exactly should a journalist do then?
First of all, ideally you'll leave those topics for your journalist buddies that actually know what they write about because they've been in medicine. If those aren't around: talk to other doctors, preferable some that are not being paid by a pharma company, to see whether they agree.
The same is true when your government tells you that all the intelligence sources agree and $desertCountry has lots of $wmd and is planning to conquer the world by doing $evilThing and $ourAlliance needs to invade now. Granted, the news media hasn't done a good job there either, you could say they were complicit by uncritically repeating propaganda.
- duxup 7y agoWill those journalist buddies ever know more than actual doctors?
- luckylion 7y agoThey'll usually know as much, and often more, yes (their job isn't to treat people but to write about treating people, that gives them more time & incentive to learn). At the very least, they know enough to be cautious when they encounter some claims. It'd be easy for me to convince a general journalist that Perl is the language of tomorrow. It'll be much harder to convince a journalist that has worked in software development and still keeps up. A journalist that has a medical background can judge these things much better, can actually read studies and understands the monetary incentives given by pharma companies - and in most cases they are not part of the game, they are not paid to shill.