3 ms·
From the article you just posted: "The ONS figures for 2015 suggest the UK’s gross contribution to the EU, before the cash rebate received by the UK, totalled
by nailer 7y ago
From the article you just posted:
"The ONS figures for 2015 suggest the UK’s gross contribution to the EU, before the cash rebate received by the UK, totalled £19.6 billion – or about £376 million a week. "
> You: see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21060090 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21060090
> Just points me back to your earlier post which says "That sets a terrible precedent: lose a vote, use every resource you can to thwart implementing the outcome, get a second vote".
Yes. You seem to not have either read or understood that point.
> That doesn't answer the question so let me try again, same question, please answer Yes or No.
Yes. However having a second referendum is spectacularly dangerous and undemocratic as you've already read, hopefully three times now. Maybe you can ingest that information, process it and even respond if you'd like to rebut it.
- tempguy9999 7y agoYes, before the cash rebate it was ~£350M/week (or £376M/week according to this). Which boris used without accounting for the rebate which would have brought it down to considerably less. He lied and you seem ok with it. > Yes. However having a second referendum is spectacularly dangerous and undemocratic as you've already read So Yes, people can change their mind, you allow, but no they shouldn't have a 2nd vote, you say, despite the fact they may have changed their mind. So what am I supposed to conclude from that? IMO it's problematic either way, but if we had a 2nd referendum at least "the will of the people" would be clearer. Which may give us a way forwards, which I proposed as a compromise, but you are trying to shut down. Your compromise/way forward is... what?
- nailer 7y agoI mentioned why the EU having control of our money is bad in a previous post you responded to and didn't read. There is no compromise. We lost. Asking people to vote a second time before disrespects the first referendum. I have explained this a fourth time. I'm blocking you now. You'll say it's because you're making amazing points, but actually it's because you're talking to yourself.
- tempguy9999 7y ago> I mentioned why the EU having control of our money is bad in a previous post and I responded "True but irrelevant. Boris lied". > Asking people to vote a second time before disrespects the first referendum "Good evening madam, please be seated" "Thank you. Let's see, I think I'll have the fish... no wait, the chicken looks good. I'll have the chick-" "NO! You will have the fish" "But I want the ch-" "Do not do this! You wanted the fish and you will have the fish" "But I changed my m-" "You are disrespecting your first choice and I cannot allow this!" Well, that's not how I see things.
- nailer 7y ago> > "The ONS figures for 2015 suggest the UK’s gross contribution to the EU, before the cash rebate received by the UK, totalled £19.6 billion – or about £376 million a week. " > "True but irrelevant. Boris lied". I mentioned you were having a discussion with yourself earlier, but thanks for providing an example. "Fish is better" "I'll have the chick-" Person A shits all over chicken before it arrives "Hah fish is better don't you want fish now?"