3 ms·
> while STILL being far ahead in the polls. This is because of the appalling state of Labour, which is currently controlled by actual communists. People are n
by mytailorisrich 7y ago
> while STILL being far ahead in the polls.
This is because of the appalling state of Labour, which is currently controlled by actual communists.
People are not stupid. Labour's current policies would be far worse than Brexit.
With a 'normal', half-decent opposition the Tories would have been overthrown years ago.
- NeedMoreTea 7y ago> Labour's current policies would be far worse than Brexit. Is that so? From the notoriously left-wing Telegraph a couple of weeks ago: "Corbyn better than no-deal Brexit, say investment banks" course they had to add "as anti-capitalist Labour wins unlikely new City fans" They try their best, bless 'em, to spin him as devil incarnate, but Citibank and Deutsche Bank sound unconvinced. The FT was much more open minded reporting the same news. Corbyn's and Labour's biggest problem is their refusal to take a side yet. "It depends" is hardly a vote winning stratagem. Had they made up their sodding mind, we might easily have had a Corbyn government by now. Most of their other policies sit well with the populace. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2019/09/03/corbyn-better-no-deal-brexit-say-investment-banks-anti-capitalist/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2019/09/03/corbyn-bette...
- mytailorisrich 7y agoI wrote that the far left would be worse than Brexit. The only way businesses might think no deal Brexit (not just Brexit) would be worse is that they hope that a communist government would be quickly voted out of power or somehow prevented from doing what they say they would do. Of course with Corbyn we would get both Brexit and the far left. I.e. the worse of both worlds. Most people still prefer the Tories to that, as shown in the polls.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoIf this Labour is communist (they're not), what on earth was Attlee's 1945 government, or pre-Blair Labour?
- mytailorisrich 7y agoAh whataboutism.... They are. Just read their manifesto and follow what they have agreed at their conference. Nationalising companies and handing over control to workers? Seizing private schools and redistributing their assets "democratically"? The Shadow Chancellor freely admits that he is a Marxist. Either some people are too young to understand what this means or they don't want to see it... And that's without even mentioning the unsavoury characters they have associated with in radical Islam and antisemitic (sorry, antisionist) circles. The party is in an appealing state. Again, the public can see that and that's why the Tories stay afloat in the polls. In the 80s the party was also far left, after catastrophic results in the 70s, and was unelectable. Thatcher was winning election after election. Edit: And as to prove me right, someone is systematically downvoting my comments within the hour. The far left never changes.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoSo. Nationalising companies is not communist per se. RBS and Northern Rock were nationalised in '08. Network Rail was re-nationalised in '13, though it was never properly private. What about Amtrak? I have seen no mention of "handing control to workers". Nor of Apparatchiks. Wouldn't be the first non-communist country to limit private education either. That said, it sure doesn't seem fully thought out - but what policy is at conference? Tory party policy certainly isn't. I seem to have lived through a very different 1970s to you. :) Most of the problems of the 1970s, throughout the West, stemmed from the abandonment of Bretton Woods and the 73 oil crisis and its after effects. Both of which fuelled rampant inflation throughout much of the West. For Britain a very significant additional part were the policies of the Heath government through 74. Overly strong unions and poor labour relations played their part, which were increasingly problematic, but on top of the systemic issues. The Tories did far worse here than Labour. It was Heath who fuelled the 72/73 boom that spectacularly crashed with the oil crisis and the 400% rise in oil price. Why? Because he was ideologically opposed to unemployment and it had risen markedly since he got elected. So he spent and spent until it went away. After the crash and oil crisis they had to abandon dozens of manifesto promises. Yet not that labour and price policy. Stagflation was born. That made Britain's "sick man of Europe" label inevitable - though there had been (much) lesser issues in the sixties that contributed. It was under Tory Heath we had the miner's strike and three day week, rationed electricity, and evenings by candle light. TV shut down at 10 to save electric. Fun Tory times. That was the last three months of the oil crisis, so there were still queues and rationing at the pumps. Labour under Wilson and Callaghan - for the rest of the 70s - was mostly attempting damage control with no money. Not surprisingly this wasn't hugely effective. Healey going to the IMF 12 or 18 months after getting elected wasn't terribly surprising either - though certainly it made life more difficult. It was Heath's unemployment reducing boom, his ridiculous income policy (and leaving Bretton Woods and that oil crisis) that fuelled the problems of the rest of the decade. Oh, and made someone replacing him as leader downright certain. It was adopting a very Heath-like incomes policy in their last year, to try an control inflation, that brought the fight with the unions and the Winter of Discontent, that ushered in Thatcher. Coldest winter for years gave a few more %% to Thatcher. Last, Thatcher was shaping up for at best a much reduced majority. More likely hung parliament or defeat, except there was this small incident called The Falklands War. Early election, huge majority. Naff all to do with economics - we were barely out of recession and still had double digit inflation, nor policy performance, just a dictator in the South Atlantic.
- EnderMB 7y agoI guess it depends who you ask. I preferred the Labour policies from the last GE, but outside of some pie-in-the-sky thinking about private education and universal credit, I think they have some solid policies. The average person doesn't care about policies, though. Labour under Ed Milliband had some good policies, but he was undone because he looked weird when eating a bacon sandwich. You could argue the same for Gordon Brown, who looked weird when he smiled when compared to the overly polished David Cameron. IMO, the people just don't like Corbyn, and many people cling to the idea that the PM is the outright ruler of the land, when Brexit has shown the exact opposite - they are a leader, but they need a house to push their majority through. I do agree with you, though. If Owen Smith had plotted a coup a few years later, he'd probably be 20-30 points ahead, and Boris would do everything possible to avoid a GE. The one good thing about Corbyn is that he is a campaigner, so the second a GE becomes a reality he'll be in his element. If Boris wins, then I give up. The Tories will have sold their soul for Brexit, the Labour party will have destroyed any credibility as a viable opposition, and the Lib Dems will have aligned too heavily with the Tories to be viable themselves. I don't know where the country goes from there, but I would love to not be a part of it.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoThe main issue with Corbyn's Labour is that it is too much on the left, with some major policies being textbook communist (e.g. nationalisations with handing control to workers), and a Marxist as Shadow Chancellor. Their current delirium about private education, which is also a textbook communist party style policy (suppression, assets seizure and "democratic" redistribution), only adds to this. I could add their populist war in private landlords and calls for rent controls... Beyond Corbyn himself this does scare many people away.
- EnderMB 7y agoI agree with you on private schools. My other half went to a private school, and her parents were in no way wealthy. She left state education because her primary school messed her education up so much she (alongside other kids in her class) failed her Year 5 SATS and refused to take the blame for not teaching the class adequately. She went from failing in Year 5 to getting a first at uni - probably thanks to a solid private education. With that being said, the current policy doesn't seem to be to scrap them entirely, but to remove their charity status. This does make sense, but will require more thought than what they've given so far. Removing their status ensures they're paying fair tax, but it also means that they are no longer required to share their facilities with state schools. It's a weird policy to lead with, and the cynic in me believes they're doing so to push the class divide, in order to get more Leave voters behind them.