5 ms·
"Unalloyed" is a strong claim - you are saying effectively that it is pure, flawless gold.
by denton-scratch 7y ago
"Unalloyed" is a strong claim - you are saying effectively that it is pure, flawless gold.
- tptacek 7y agoI can't think of anything bad about it. One popular strain of criticism is clearly bogus, that it removes a measure of visibility from network operators (that's the point). Another is that it centralizes DNS services at companies like Cloud Flare, which, no, you can run your own DoH resolver server (and probably shouldn't use Cloud Flare regardless). Finally, people say that it's clunky compared to datagram-based alternatives; from my perspective, DNS has been hampered by the UDP service model for decades, and revisiting it so that, at least at the retail level, it's TCP/HTTPS like everything else is an opportunity, not a problem.
- axaxs 7y agoSerious question - why do you prefer DoH vs say, DNS over TLS? The former always seemed rather hacky to me.
- tptacek 7y agoI don't think there's anything wrong with DoT, but DoH is deliberately more difficult to block, which is a sensible design goal for a privacy and anti-censorship protocol. Both are better than directly using legacy plaintext DNS.
- juped 7y ago>you can run your own DoH resolver server How does this work in your mind?
- tptacek 7y agoI don't understand your question. The first Google SERP will give you a multiplicity of tutorials on setting up a DoH server.
- juped 7y agoAt the point when I would be "run[ning] my own DoH resolver", I'm already at the point of setting up my own resolver. Why wouldn't I just turn on unbound and call it a day?
- tptacek 7y agoThe point of running your own DoH resolver is that you're doing it somewhere off-network, to tunnel DNS out of an ISP network you don't trust to somewhere else you trust more. You can also just not run DoH if you trust your network. I'm saying DoH is a good thing, not that everyone has to use it.
- juped 7y agoAlright, but the reason for the complaint about centralization you're dismissing is that most people are encountering DoH via Firefox's plan to default resolve via DoH to Cloudflare, rather than in the context of being deft Unix hands searching for a way to tunnel their DNS out of an untrustworthy network.
- tptacek 7y agoI do not think a feature that delegates DNS to Cloud Flare is an unalloyed good. I think the protocol is. The distinction is important.
- denton-scratch 7y agoOh. Well, I lean to the view that X-over-HTTP is often a bad model; partly because HTTP has been heavily-commercialized. I can see that there are problems with DNS; there always have been, and it's always been obvious. But for now, I think I prefer running my own resolver. Unbound is really easy to set up.
- tptacek 7y ago