3 ms·
The efficiency of electric assist doesn't really matter. They get decent range with a small battery, so you can just use a modestly larger battery to get more r
by maxerickson 7y ago
The efficiency of electric assist doesn't really matter. They get decent range with a small battery, so you can just use a modestly larger battery to get more range.
I'm not saying more range from the same battery would be worthless, just that the ranges they already offer are plenty marketable.
I also wonder about the efficiency of a small (tiny!), slow generator.
- chrismorgan 7y agoYou’re generally correct, especially with how people mostly use bicycles and e-bikes. But it depends a bit on how you’re positioning it; two interesting cases that I’m thinking of: using a “trickle power assist” to cheat your way to effectively 100% efficiency, so it needs to be efficient with small augmentations from a battery (which I think is the sort of case that would commonly be particularly inefficient, but when combined with your pedalling in the same drivetrain I imagine it might not be); and velomobiles for longer-distance travel (very much more being a car replacement), perhaps even touring, where larger range figures start to matter more. If you can get it to go 20% further at a given speed, that becomes a bigger deal. A substantial art of this thought experiment is about designing a delightful product. As my dad said to me: if Apple were designing a bicycle or tricycle or velomobile or similar, what would it be like? We both agreed that there wouldn’t be an exposed chain, for starters, and I suspect that they’d at least try to do away with the chain altogether, and they’d care about efficiencies if they went down this path.