3 ms·
I always find it strange how language materials insist on presenting agglutination as cases. I was lucky enough to not have it when I studied Turkish, so for me
by dmitriid 7y ago
I always find it strange how language materials insist on presenting agglutination as cases. I was lucky enough to not have it when I studied Turkish, so for me the
- -da is "in", not "locative case"
- -(y)a is "towards", not "locative case"
etc.
I personally find that insisting that students learn proper case names greatly hinders the learning process.
Finnish and Estonian are also agglutinative, and I feel abject horror reading about "essive", "comitative", "abessive" and other cases. Stahp! :)
- NoodleIncident 7y agoFrom The Fine Article: > The extent of irregularity came as a shock. I had always believed that the Finno-Ugric family of languages, to which Estonian belongs, was “agglutinative” – that is, with words being formed by adding strings of endings in a regular way. Estonian has far more irregularity than this would suggest: consonant gradation can make forms difficult to recognise, and every putative rule seems to have exceptions.
- Mediterraneo10 7y ago> Finnish and Estonian are also agglutinative Finnish and Estonian are synthetic languages now. While the Proto-Uralic language ancestral to them both was more agglutinative, the system of consonant gradation (and subsequent loss of consonants) as it developed in these languages means they are no longer very agglutinative. In a purely agglutinative language you only have to memorize one stem for a word and then you can add all case endings to that one stem. In Finnish, you have to memorize at least two stems (strong and weak stems). In Estonian, things are even more complicated.
- Gravityloss 7y agoCurrent limitations of English centric software language parsing means it's annoying to type machine generated or parseable text in Finnish. For example pinging people in Facebook comments doesn't work with correct Finnish. English: "this would be useful to @Pekka" Correct Finnish: "tämä olisi hyödyllistä @Pekalle". Machine parseable but incorrect Finnish: "tämä olisi hyödyllistä @Pekka :lle" It would probably be possible to make a library to understand the transformed forms of words.
- anticensor 7y agoConsonant gradation/assimilation happens at the surface phonology and do not affect the morphological ground form. We have a similar voicing assimilation in Turkish; however, devoicing is progressively applied and do not propagate more than one syllable, unlike Finnish.