4 ms·
You could tell him that if he proceeds he'd inflict the same pain he's in now to his friends & relatives. Maybe that would work?
by Nextgrid 7y ago
You could tell him that if he proceeds he'd inflict the same pain he's in now to his friends & relatives. Maybe that would work?
- ambicapter 7y agoholy god please don't ever talk to a suicidal person in a manner designed to guilt or shame them ever.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoWhy not?
- ralmeida 7y agoBecause it may backfire and increase the probability that they follow through.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoIt may also work and decrease the probability that they follow through. Every strategy has its successes and its failures. If that were a reason not to do something, you'd never do anything.
- ralmeida 7y agoFair enough. There is indeed a chance that, counterintuitively, "burdening" the at-risk person with the consequences of their acts may work. However, whose "burden of proof" is it? Should "OP" provide evidence to their claim or you to yours? If no claims are provided, what should the "default action" be? I argue that, in face of the extreme consequences of the proposed action ("burdening" instead of "no burdening"), "no burdening" should be the default action, unless there's evidence that "burdening" works (which none of us in the conversation have so far provided).
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> I argue that, in face of the extreme consequences of the proposed action ("burdening" instead of "no burdening"), "no burdening" should be the default action You're wholeheartedly endorsing the idea I was using to mock you: >> Every strategy has its successes and its failures. If that were a reason not to do something, you'd never do anything. The consequences of, in your terminology, "no burdening" are just as extreme as the consequences of "burdening". That's obvious, because they are exactly the same consequences. And the evidence that people will avoid doing things they might otherwise do, even at significant cost to themselves, for the sake of their family and close friends, is abundant.
- ralmeida 7y ago> And the evidence that people will avoid doing things they might otherwise do, even at significant cost to themselves, for the sake of their family and close friends, is abundant. Rational people, maybe. People on the verge of suicide are not acting rationally. Where's the citable evidence for the claim that "shaming/guilting/burdening suicidal people makes them less likely to commit suicide"?
- thaumasiotes 7y agoLook at what happened when a person who was actually suicidal shared the viewpoint that worked for him, in public: https://www.popehat.com/2016/04/21/what-empathy-looks-like-twitch-streamer-brandon-nance-resigns-after-ranting-at-a-depressed-fan/ https://www.popehat.com/2016/04/21/what-empathy-looks-like-t... With that level of public openmindedness, the citable evidence (of which this is a part) is guaranteed to dramatically understate the actual effectiveness of the approach.
- ralmeida 7y agoI don't think I'm following here. The viewer was suicidal, but wasn't anymore when he was berated. My interpretation from your link is that "watching videos of someone playing games helped a viewer not commit suicide". How's this evidence for advocating berating people while (not after) they are suicidal?
- DanBC 7y agoWatch the video on this page. It has interviews of people who survived a suicide attempt. https://www.kent.gov.uk/social-care-and-health/health/release-the-pressure https://www.kent.gov.uk/social-care-and-health/health/releas... Here's a transcript: https://www.kent.gov.uk/social-care-and-health/health/release-the-pressure/release-the-pressure-video-transcript https://www.kent.gov.uk/social-care-and-health/health/releas... They already feel immense amounts of shame. Adding to that shame just re-affirms what they already think, it confirms their distorted thinking that everyone would be better off without them. The distorted thinking runs something like: "Only an arsehole would kill themselves and leave their family to deal with it, and I'm thinking of killing myself, therefore I am an arsehole. And I'm so terrible that they would in fact be better off without me."
- thaumasiotes 7y agoDoes it have interviews of people who didn't make a suicide attempt because they were guilted out of it? The dangers of not making a suicide attempt are so low we usually don't even bother to call out "survivors".
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dropin685 7y agoNo! -- at least, that's not what's suggested in the (excellent) course which DanBC linked to. An eye opener for me! Don't divert the focus to others. And (this is my take) don't be talking about what the person mustn't do -- they already feel boxed in! The goal is to steer toward a positive outcome. The course deals with this (and other) points better than I can. Recommended! https://www.zerosuicidealliance.com/training/ https://www.zerosuicidealliance.com/training/
- homonculus1 7y agoNot likely IMO. Telling him that ending his suffering makes him a bad person is just adding weight. Suicide isn't a linear decision that can be logically eliminated; it's a vortex of feeling trapped, hopeless, guilty, etc. that needs to be disrupted somehow.
- DanBC 7y agoNo. Watch the video on this page: https://www.kent.gov.uk/social-care-and-health/health/release-the-pressure https://www.kent.gov.uk/social-care-and-health/health/releas... People already feel huge amounts of shame about the pain that they're inflicting upon other people. Calling them selfish just re-affirms what they're already feeling, makes them feel worse, and increases the risk that they'll die.
- jodrellblank 7y agoFrom the "beatings will continue until morale improves" school of things. "If he feels like shit, maybe making him feel worse will help?"