3 ms·
A pity. - The previous parliamentary session was the longest since the civil war (the English one if you're American). - This prorogue was for an extra four d
by nailer 7y ago
A pity.
- The previous parliamentary session was the longest since the civil war (the English one if you're American).
- This prorogue was for an extra four days - which seems quite reasonable considering:
1. there are politicians, who previously campaigned on the losing side of the referendum, bent on hampering negotiations by making the UK accept any deal the EU offers, which is likely to result in a one-sided deal for the UK
2. the last few days of the negotiations are likely to be critical.
- pjc50 7y ago> The previous parliamentary session was the longest since the civil war Yes, that in itself was exceptional for no good reason - I think the intent there was to avoid having another Queen's Speech before the deadline, back when the deadline was in May. The negotiations have been carried out on a delusional basis. The EU is not going to cave at the last minute and there's never even been consistency on the UK side about what we want.
- benj111 7y ago"there are politicians, who previously campaigned on the losing side of the referendum, bent on hampering negotiations by making the UK accept any deal the EU offers" Like what? Mays deal that MPs rejected?
- makomk 7y agoYes, like May's deal that MPs rejected. One of the fundamental things you need to understand in order to make sense of what's going on in Parliament is that none of the Brexit-related options have the support of a majority of MPs and it's unlikely they ever will unless there's another general election. So the only way for anything to get a majority is for a bunch of MPs who disagree on what they want to ally with each other in order to vote against one of the other options. Also, a general election would most likely have given Boris Johnson the majority he needs to push through no-deal Brexit, which a majority of MPs oppose.
- nailer 7y agoLike campaigning to accept any deal.
- benj111 7y agoWho's campaigning to accept any deal? The whole problem is ~50% of parliament want to remain, the other half don't all agree on what deal they want. So if there is a subset that will accept any deal, there clearly isnt enough to make a difference about anything.
- nailer 7y agoThe remain folks are campaigning against no deal being on the table, which forces the UK to accept any deal.
- benj111 7y agoYou seem to be poor at basic logic. Against no deal != in favour of / having to accept, any deal.
- nailer 7y agoYou should improve your own logic. 'Against no deal' does not mean 'no deal must not be on the table'. The PM is against no deal. He has stated so many, many times. He also understands that the UK must be prepared to walk away in order to get a reasonable deal. Do you understand that?
- viraptor 7y ago> This prorogue was for an extra four days That's not true. The prorogation was for 5 weeks. This does include the planned recess of 3 weeks, but it's not a forced recess. Given the importance of what's going on, it could be adjusted/cancelled. You can't say "it's 4 extra days, because I expected you'd do the usual even though the situation is extraordinary". There was clear opposition to that before the prorogation was officially announced.
- nailer 7y agoYes it is. Four extra sitting days: https://order-order.com/2019/08/28/boriss-prorogation-will-shorter-majors/ https://order-order.com/2019/08/28/boriss-prorogation-will-s... As you mention, it's a vital time. The democratic mandate from the general public outweighs parliament's attempts to interfere in negotiations. Prorouging provides an excellent mechanism to allow the PM to focus on negotiations that deliver what people voted for.
- viraptor 7y agoFrom the actual letter: > This morning I spoke to Her Majesty The Queen to request an end to the current parliamentary session in the second sitting week in September, before commencing the second session of this Parliament with a Queen’s speech on Monday 14 October. It's ~a month. Unless he can guarantee the recess would happen, I'm counting it as a month.
- matthewmacleod 7y agoYou have failed to read the judgement handed down. These issues are explicitly dealt with and you are not correct. Please don’t spread misinformation.