3 ms·
So 'obviously illegal' that a high court previously dismissed the case as out of scope of the law?
by OJFord 7y ago
So 'obviously illegal' that a high court previously dismissed the case as out of scope of the law?
- shakna 7y agoThe High Court in the UK does not generally rule on matters of Parliament. A matter undertaken by the Parliament may still have been illegal, but not under their purview, because of that.
- stordoff 7y agoNeither does the Supreme Court[1]. Prorogation is different in that it is not a proceeding of Parliament, but imposed upon them by the usage of the prerogative powers. [1] It is forbidden from doing so by the Bill of Rights 1688: That the Freedome of Speech and Debates or Proceedings in Parlyament ought not to be impeached or questioned in any Court or Place out of Parlyament.
- robin_reala 7y agoAnd another high court unanimously ruled it as inside the scope of the law. I think it’s obvious at this point that the English High Court got it wrong this time.
- benj111 7y agoI don't think its fair to say the lower court got it wrong, the written and case law here is, sparse. TBH either way it was going to get appealed so the judges decision is moot. I certainly wouldn't be wanting to make the decision, and I'm sure he thought it was above his pay grade also.
- OJFord 7y ago> And another high court unanimously ruled it as inside the scope of the law. Sure, but if high courts are disagreeing about whether it's even within the scope of the law at all, isn't it a bit much to call it 'obviously illegal', i.e. not only in 'obviously' in scope, but also with 'obvious' ruling?
- celticninja 7y agoOne did, one didn't, then the mother of those two courts came and sorted it out. Now the court that was wrong understands why it was wrong. It doesn't resent the decision.
- OJFord 7y agoI understand that, I'm just highlighting that perhaps a HN commenter (and I include myself) doesn't trump a high court on what's 'obvious' when it comes to the law.
- samsari 7y agoWell, the High Court in England ruled it was not justiciable since it does not have the authority to do otherwise.
- OJFord 7y agoThus, in its eyes, precluding it from being 'illegal'. And thus, in my eyes, precluding it from being 'obviously' illegal!