3 ms·
I’m interested in the idea of going not just chainless, but not having any rigid or semi-rigid drive connection at all. I ride a recumbent tricycle, and an int
by chrismorgan 7y ago
I’m interested in the idea of going not just chainless, but not having any rigid or semi-rigid drive connection at all.
I ride a recumbent tricycle, and an interesting complaint from my dad when we were discussing why recumbent trikes and velomobiles aren’t more widespread is that the design is unweildy, that the end result doesn’t look polished; so we discussed ways that you could make it neater. The chain on recumbent trikes goes from the very front to the back of the vehicle, so it’s a long, subjectively unsightly thing. Something like the this Driven shaft drive would be quite unsuitable for a trike due to the length of the shafts that would be required, and the resulting torsion.
So then, we wondered, what would it be like if you replaced the entire drivetrain with an electric drivetrain? Pedals at the front would drive a generator, which would pass power through slim wires hidden inside the frame or similar, to a motor at the back. Much neater, visually if in no other way. This would fit in very nicely with making it an e-bike, too: precise legislation wording could be problematic, but your 200W or 250W or whatever would be added to whatever power you generated by pedalling. And by being a fully-electric drivetrain, efficiency would be improved on the electric assist. (Probably similar to the benefits that I understand going full-electric on hybrid car drivetrains can offer.)
I’m not deeply familiar with the efficiencies involved, but my impression from light research is that regular chain drives start out at up to 97% but often operate at figures closer to 80–85% due to wear and lack of maintenance; and a full electric drivetrain could be over 90% efficient, though it’d be more likely to be around 80%. (Remember, we’re not getting a battery involved at this point, so no losses on that.) Perhaps such a drive would be on par with a typical chain drive for efficiency, though less than a well-maintained one; but it could provide improvements in efficiency in other areas (electric assist and foot-to-bike power transference).
I believe that less maintenance would be required, and it’d the complaint of the dirtiness of bike chains too. Heavier parts and more expensive, unless you were going e-bike already in which case it may be lighter and cheaper, which would become a much more obvious thing to do for such a bike.
It’s interesting to think about. But I doubt I’ll ever do any practical experimentation on the idea, because my list of projects I’d love to work on is already more than thirty years long (and getting longer each year), and this sits a fair way back on it.
Hydraulics would also be interesting to experiment with. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chainless_bicycle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chainless_bicycle is a good page to start on for learning about all these things.
- maxerickson 7y agoThe efficiency of electric assist doesn't really matter. They get decent range with a small battery, so you can just use a modestly larger battery to get more range. I'm not saying more range from the same battery would be worthless, just that the ranges they already offer are plenty marketable. I also wonder about the efficiency of a small (tiny!), slow generator.
- chrismorgan 7y agoYou’re generally correct, especially with how people mostly use bicycles and e-bikes. But it depends a bit on how you’re positioning it; two interesting cases that I’m thinking of: using a “trickle power assist” to cheat your way to effectively 100% efficiency, so it needs to be efficient with small augmentations from a battery (which I think is the sort of case that would commonly be particularly inefficient, but when combined with your pedalling in the same drivetrain I imagine it might not be); and velomobiles for longer-distance travel (very much more being a car replacement), perhaps even touring, where larger range figures start to matter more. If you can get it to go 20% further at a given speed, that becomes a bigger deal. A substantial art of this thought experiment is about designing a delightful product. As my dad said to me: if Apple were designing a bicycle or tricycle or velomobile or similar, what would it be like? We both agreed that there wouldn’t be an exposed chain, for starters, and I suspect that they’d at least try to do away with the chain altogether, and they’d care about efficiencies if they went down this path.
- ralphhughes 7y agoAs a slightly related precedent, some early trucks used an engine->generator->wires->electric motor system as an electric transmission as this worked better than the early gearboxes. On a bicycle, the wiring would certainly be easy and considerably lighter than shafts, chains or hydraulics. You would take a hit on efficiency as pedaling force would have to be converted to electricity and then back to motion, but generators and motors are pretty good these days. Weight could be an issue, but again the developments in hub motors have seen the weight come down a lot to the point that your idea seems viable.