4 ms·
This is a great example of why quantitative research isn't always enough, and this sort of "ethnography" of suicide qualitative research is also important. Some
by ineedasername 7y ago
This is a great example of why quantitative research isn't always enough, and this sort of "ethnography" of suicide qualitative research is also important. Some times you have to find out what the ground conditions are that generate the data in order to really understand what's going on & generate insights.
- austinjp 7y agoIndeed. Hard to design a double blinded, randomised, placebo controlled trial for suicide prevention.
- dmix 7y agoI was thinking the same for economics. How can you really measure all of the side effects of a government policy? For ex: if the conditions in a marketplace are so bad (for ex: because of a monopoly, or gov-back entrenched businesses, or other useless barriers to entry) that no one ever even tries to start a business, so there's no one ever to complains and nothing to measure. At most you have some increasingly out-of-date information from before the policy was implemented, when the wider market, technology, access to capital, etc has changed. Another example is minimum wage laws, it's very difficult to measure what costs there were if the jobs simply weren't created, not simply going declining in existing businesses or measurable marketplace. Combined with the countless other factors which influence hiring and cyclical trends. I'm not sure what the solution is here but I'm skeptical of a lot of economic research.
- gowld 7y agoHow is this not quantitative research? It's counting pieces of information. All data analys comes from data. Quantitative research can't exist at all without it.
- ineedasername 7y agoThere's certainly a quantitative component. It's easy and often useful to add some such components to qualitative research. But getting into the field, tagging along with the death investigator, seeing the whole process from begining to end, that's qualitative. You're seeing much more than just all of the numeric data captured. I'm not saying quantitative research can exist without data, I'm not sure where you got that idea. But not all data is quantitative. Data that is non-numeric is qualitative data. A case-study, for example, is often qualitative, though incorporating plenty of numeric data in support.