17 ms·
Germany's Vanishing Monasteries
- Krasnol 7y ago30 years might be enough to become a popular retreat from technology. They just need proper online marketing.
- wolfgke 7y ago> 30 years might be enough to become a popular retreat from technology. They just need proper online marketing. Was the contradiction between these two sentences an actually intended stylistic device ("retreat from technology" vs. "proper online marketing")?
- Krasnol 7y agoYes ;)
- homonculus1 7y agoThe stylistic device in question is known commonly as a "joke".
- hos234 7y agoAs membership declines, just wondering what happens to all the cash the Churches are sitting on, from property, to art, to chuch tax collections. Going to be interesting to see what the next (younger) gen of church leaders do with it...maybe they need an innovation center to modernize the useful aspects of religion.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- number6 7y agoMoney will find it's way
- TomMarius 7y agoShould be given back to people.
- hunta2097 7y agoEurope is in a post-christianity phase, it's going to be interesting. I'm guessing they would have no choice but to sell off property and land to pay their clergy? In the UK lots of churches have either been converted to housing or commercial venues. It's really weird going to a kid's play center in an impressive old church but it happens: https://twitter.com/RainbowFunTqy https://twitter.com/RainbowFunTqy
- keiferski 7y agoPittsburgh has quite a few former churches that are now bars, breweries, music venues, or other cultural centers. Here's a popular one: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Church_Brew_Works https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Church_Brew_Works
- twic 7y agoThere's also a business of subletting church buildings to other churches. I once wandered into St Dunstan in the West, just off Fleet Street in London, and found that there was a Romanian orthodox service in full swing.
- skissane 7y agoBut will the membership decline continue in the long-run? Within the Catholic church, there is a traditionalist/conservative minority, who are growing basically through having a high birth rate – rejecting contraception and pre-marital sex, they tend to marry young and have lots of kids. Not all of those kids will follow in their parents' footsteps, but the majority of them probably will. Though these conservatives/traditionalists are a minority now, as the decades pass by their numbers will grow and grow, and may eventually grow to the point of no longer being a minority within Catholicism[1], but instead becoming the new majority. At that point, the decline may rebound into a new period of growth. [1] a minority in wealthy countries like Germany. Leaving Catholicism in places like Africa out of the discussion, because the situation there is very different
- avar 7y agoEurope has entire countries where pretty much 100% of the population were extremist Catholic zealots with huge families by modern standards just a couple of hundred years ago. Today those countries have some of the lowest birth rates in Europe, e.g. Spain and Italy[1] pretty much trail the pack. The data suggests that your hypothesis is false. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_the_European_Union https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_the_European_U...
- keiferski 7y agoThe above commenter was referencing specific populations, not entire countries. A good comparable example might be Orthodox Jews, which are projected to become the majority of the Jewish population in a short period of time (because of high birth rates, among other reasons.) However I'm not sure if the equivalent Christian groups are as prevalent in Europe. High birth rates are an important aspect of Orthodox demographics: They are the most reproductive of all Jews, and ultra-Orthodox communities have some of the highest rates in the world, with 6 children per an average household. Non-existent levels of intermarriage (unlike some liberal Jewish denominations, Orthodoxy vehemently opposes the phenomenon) also contribute to their growing share in the world's Jewish population. While American Orthodox are but 10% of all Jews, among children, their share rises immensely: An estimated 61% of Jewish children in New York belong to Orthodox households, 49% to ultra-Orthodox. Similar patterns are observed in Britain and other countries. With present trends sustained, Orthodox Jews are projected to numerically dominate British Jewry by 2031, and American Jewry by 2058. However, their growth is balanced by large numbers of members leaving their communities and observant lifestyle. Among the 2013 PEW respondents, 17% of those under 30 who were raised Orthodox disaffiliated (in earlier generations, this trend was far more prevalent, and 77% of those over 65 left). It is estimated that over 20% of those raised religious Zionist in Israel disaffiliate, and greater numbers adopt a secularized lifestyle and define themselves as "living on the spectrum (of religion)". Loose observance among young adults is common even when they retain formal affiliation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orthodox_Judaism#Demographics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orthodox_Judaism#Demographics
- roel_v 7y ago"from property" In my Dutch town, there are churches that have been converted to hotels, a night club, several bicycle parkings, an award-winning bookshop that promptly went bankrupt, an indoor playground and a slew of restaurants. Others are just torn down. It seems the church has a preference for the last, but many of the expensive ones to maintain (i.e., the ones they want to get rid of first) are monuments and have to be preserved. There is one I can see from my window that has been under renovation for 20-something years; every couple of years there is a 'competition' to find someone with the best plan of what to do with it, and they never find anyone because a) it's a monument so you're very restricted in what modifications you can do with it; and b) it's very expensive to maintain (let alone renovate). So yeah, whatever money they have remaining in art etc has been dumped into pretty much worthless property over the last decades. A few of the remaining nuns around my corner distribute a door to door church flyer once every few months (blissfully ignoring any 'no advertising' stickers on any mailbox, bless their hearts), and they report on the financial state of the parish in it every once in a while - judging from how excited they sound when they've collected a few 100 at a service that drew a large crowd, it's not all glitter and gold in the church (at the lower levels at least). Oh and another church around the corner (I have literally a dozen within a 1km radius from my house) sells christmas trees from their parking lot every year to keep the heating on - not exactly a sign of opulence either.
- gambiting 7y agoIn the meantime, Poland is not only building lots of new churches, it even builds new cathedrals adorned in gold[0]. Even the little town I'm from(only 20k population) has 3 churches, and they are all full of gold and it's common knowledge that the local priests are most likely one of the wealthiest people around. [0]This was only finished in 2004, and is the most disgustingly oppulent building I have ever seen: https://pl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bazylika_Naj%C5%9Bwi%C4%99tszej_Maryi_Panny_Liche%C5%84skiej_w_Licheniu_Starym https://pl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bazylika_Naj%C5%9Bwi%C4%99tsze... You'd think all of this would turn people away from the church, but it doesn't seem that way - each church usually has to hold 4-5 masses every Sunday and for every one the church is full to the brim, with people standing outside because there's no more room in the church itself.
- mcv 7y agoDo churches have so much money? Young churches are frequently short on money (which they need primarily to rent a building and to hire a preacher). Older churches have lots of buildings, but are rarely swimming in cash these days.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tathougies 7y agoCatholic religious priests (religious here means they are part of an order, like monks) cant be paid a salary. They have to rely on alms and their orders money since theyve taken personal vows of poverty
- hnal943 7y agoChurches in America are funded by the people that attend them. I think churches in Europe actually receive tax money, which changes the equation pretty significantly.
- mcv 7y agoChurches in Europe are funded by the people that attend them. At least Dutch churches are, but I think this is true in most European countries. A long time ago, they were indeed funded by tax, at least some churches in some countries, but that's changed with a better understanding of the separation of church and state.
- rambojazz 7y agoI hope at least all their physical properties (artworks, churches, monasteries, land) goes to the state and is used for social good.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mschaef 7y agoSpeaking from experience in the Philadelphia region, the legacy of old buildings is something of a burden. The area I'm in now was built up before cars were commonplace - implication being churches built closely enough to be within walking distance. Flash forward a century, and the situation is a combination of fewer people attending churches and more ability for those that do to travel. There are also more competing interests for people's time, so there's less ability and desire for parishioners to engage in volunteer activities at churches. Attending church on Sunday morning might mean missing a little league game and attending a work day at the parish might mean missing a school event or similar. (With fewer activities centered around church than before, there's more opportunity for schedule contention that the churches often lose.) What this means for an individual parish is that there are fewer resources available for maintaining an aging and likely historic building. There are fewer people committing money to the church and fewer people able to volunteer work at the church. The flip side of this is that there are also fewer practical reasons to maintain an old church. Shutting down a church with 50 people in weekly attendance is easier than shutting down a church with 300 people in attendance. The trouble with this line of reasoning is that it papers over some of the more sentimental reasons for keeping a parish running. Those 50 remaining folks are also the people most likely to have a strong connection to the parish... or they'd have already left. So individual parishes can have more inertia to stay open than you might expect. Moving up to the diocese level, a parish shutting down can transfer many of the funding/transport issues from the parish to the diocese. The diocese, which may have problems of its own, now has additional burdens to take on as it both loses revenue (from parish remittances) and gains expenses. This implies a potentially strong incentive for a diocese to sell off old properties. The trouble with a sale is the large number of stakeholders that might be opposed to such a sale. Never underestimate the difficulties that can be thrown up by 'interested parties'. Shutting down a parish can easily involve current and former parishoners, the diocese level, local planning/zoning boards, historical building regulations... the list goes on and on. (And you still have to find a developer with the intent, resources, and ability to take on the property and turn it into something the community wants.) The reason I go down this path is mainly to illustrate that the notion of churches as pools of free resources is somewhat dubious at best. Whatever resources are there are not only special purpose to begin with, but also can sequestered behind history, regulation, and interests that are difficult to overcome.
- giardini 7y agoTurn them into bed-and-breakfast inns or hotels. Hire some Indians to help (there's a caste that specializes in maintaining hotels/inns/etc. and are very good at it) if necessary. Get the monastery off the public dole if possible.
- keiferski 7y agoI would love to see old monasteries turned into various kinds of retreats. The idea of spending a week or a month with no electronics, all my meals prepared, and quiet time to just read, study and think sounds fantastic.
- iguy 7y agoThis is already possible, I'm told that many monasteries accept visitors, for a week or two, who are basically expected to be quiet and polite.
- incompatible 7y agoI once visited as a tourist the monastery at Montserrat near Barcelona. I was quite looking forward to rustic home-made bread, cheese, and wine, but unfortunately they'd outsourced the cafe to a secular organization.
- dagw 7y agoDon't retreats like that already exist. Why does it have to be an old monastery. And anyway I thought the whole point of a monastery was that everybody helped out with the cooking, gardening, chores etc. not that you had servants waiting on you.
- masklinn 7y ago> The idea of spending a week or a month with no electronics, all my meals prepared, and quiet time to just read, study and think sounds fantastic. If you just want a hostel / retreat, many monasteries already provide that service through their guest-houses. I think it would be way more interesting and useful to be able to actually be part of the community save for the religious part: taking part in the preparation and work, and be able to engage in one's secular activity (study, projects, reading, …) during the periods where monks engage in religious activities. Of course the issue with that is there is little incentive for churches to subsidise such inviduals (unlike even the lay brothers of old).
- safsafsafa 7y agoMost monasteries accept, and have always accepted, visitors for this very reason. On guy even made a movie, "Into Great Silence"
- xxxpupugo 7y ago> Religious orders in Germany are disappearing because so few people want to dedicate their entire lives to God anymore Is there anything weird about this? Entire life is a pretty hefty price to pay, what needs to be changed is religion itself, if it wants to find more new believers to keep itself from disappearing.
- bakuninsbart 7y agoI honestly think the acceptance of homosexuality in the mainstream is having a huge influence. A hundred years ago when society would tell you that what you want to do is wrong - and you might even believe it yourself - then choosing a life as a priest or monk was a serious alternative. - You would have a way to paradise and nobody would question you not marrying. It is of course complete conjecture, although more and more info is coming out on the "homosexual lobby" in the Vatican.
- usrusr 7y agoAbsolutely. And I consider it a general principle, not limited to homosexuality at all: in preindividualistic times (pretty much coincides with preindustrial), if you were in any way unfit for the path laid out for you by birth, the monastery might be an option. Simple rules and low expectations (industrial armies often fill a similar role during peacetime). Getting into good terms with your imaginary friend would be mostly a rationalisation/excuse for bailing out.
- aeneasmackenzie 7y ago>religion needs less restrictions lukewarm religions are dying out. It's atheism or a religion that makes demands -- and the atheists are not reproducing.
- dschuetz 7y agoIs there any possible modern approach to a traditional catholic monastery? I think, they are dying out, because of their rigid traditions which rarely make sense in our modern world anymore. The idea of a monastery is to dedicate yourself completely to introspection and philosophy, and serving the monastery with its inhabitants, no matter what religion or philosophy. Why are they having so much trouble to keep up with changes? They just accept the changes without adapting? Why?
- incompatible 7y agoWe could try science / engineering monasteries as described by Neal Stephenson in Anathem?
- dr_dshiv 7y agoIf you go back to the earliest monasteries, it would be the Pythagoreans of southern Italy c.525BC. They conducted the first attested hypothesis-driven scientific experiments -- while pursuing a simple, spiritual and communal lifestyle. Josephus and Philo of Alexandria described the Essenes and Therapeuts as Pythagorean -- and those monastic groups are largely where Christian monasticism emerged from.
- dschuetz 7y agoThat's an interesting idea. Definitely worth thinking about. An R&D monastery, where the inhabitants support each other by rotating duties and service for day-to-day life, with dedication to science, engineering and philosophy. Sounds great to me.
- rpmisms 7y agoThat would almost be a regression, as for a long time, monasteries were the intellectual strongholds of the West.
- cat199 7y agothis is what the 'univerity' is or was intended to be, at its base. there is a reason universities have 'faculties' (e.g. 'faculties' of the 'body of knowledge') and that key persons are called 'deans'
- mgnn 7y agoThe Concent of Saunt Leibniz. We can try turning old monasteries into concents à la Neal Stephenson's Anathem. People can go for a year in a unarian math to just study. Maybe a four consecutive years in such a math get equivalent recognition to a university degree. Whether it is the traditional monastic discipline or the Cartasian discipline, the required basic infrastructure is probably similar. Jeejahs stay outside, of course. Particularly determined professors can populate a decennarian, maybe even a centenarian. Also, isn't there only about 9 years before our scheduled visit by the Icosahedron?
- sdenton4 7y agoMy thoughts exactly! I don't have a whole lot of patience for prayer, but near-infinite time for mathing it up sounds amazing...
- sixplusone 7y agoor a monastery to write code (open source, ofc), when hackathons aren't enough, and (FAANG) campuses too much.
- powerset 7y agoSign me up!
- k__ 7y agoThe just have to stell themselves better. Living in a monasteries is strongly coupled with a long and healthy life. Most nuns look at least 10 years younger than they are.
- pelasaco 7y agoThis phrase "Religious orders in Germany are disappearing because so few people want to dedicate their entire lives to God anymore." is not accurate at all. We have a lot of people wanting to dedicate their entire lives to God, but eventually not for the Catholic Church. It's 2019, 6% of the German population is Muslim, Spiegel!
- recursinging 7y agoThe village I live in has a "Kloster", with nuns making up about 15% of our population. The article is accurate in that the number of practicing nuns is sinking and certainly not sustainable. Here they have diversified in a number of directions. There is a school, an old folks home, and a hotel. The picturesque location, combined with the historic buildings makes all these quite competitive, and successful. I'd go so far as to say the church here is thriving despite the declining popularity of dedicating your life to it.
- pluma 7y agoKeep in mind that in Germany these "church operated" services are heavily subsidised by the German state via regular taxes (not the "church tax" registered church members pay directly to their church via the tax office). In some cases this can be as much as 100% of the operating costs and salaries (although the business is operated in accordance with church labor laws rather than secular laws, allowing e.g. certain forms of discrimination and removing certain protections). Maintaining churches, monasteries and church operated services is almost never about finances.
- wsy 7y agoThis description is a bit misleading: - School: Germany mostly has public schools. If you have operated a private school for a few years, you can apply for subsidy. You will receive roughly the amount per pupil that would otherwise be needed to fund the pupil's place at a public school. So this is more or less a zero-sum game for the state. All schools have to obey public school regulations (e.g., on curriculum and exams) regardless who operates them. - Elderly home: there is no direct subsidy by the state. Germany has established a mandatory insurance ("Pflegeversicherung", nursing care insurance). This insurance will pay for nursing care, regardless who operates the elderly home. - Hotel: no subsidy by the state at all. Summarized, there exists no special deal by the state for church operated services, with respect to funding/subsidy.
- idoubtit 7y agoFrom Wikidepia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Church_tax#Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Church_tax#Germany About 70% of church revenues come from church tax (Kirchensteuer). This is about €9.2 billion (in 2010).
- lukebuehler 7y agoGreat article, but I think it misses one key aspect of why monasteries are dying out: the lack of lively church communities which used to encourage dedicated people to join the monastic life. Monasteries don't exist in a vacuum, they have an intricate interdependency with normal parishes of families and, more generally, people "in the world." It should not really be the responsibility of monastics to do public relations to get people to choose this kind of life. A good example is the abbot from the article, he grew up a parish, was an altar server, etc., that made it possible for him to even conceive of this kind of life style--something that is just too big of a chasm for most non-church people nowadays.
- twic 7y agoWasn't it the case that a lot of second sons became monks because they weren't going to inherit the family title/land/business/farm, and they had to find some way to survive? For the upper classes, monasteries were replaced by militaries, when second sons could go off and have adventures, and perhaps win a fortune of their own. For everyone else, the advent of wage economies did the job.
- pjmlp 7y agoAnd in some cases, the only path to literacy.
- duxup 7y agoThe impression that I always got was that the church, in some role or another, was it's own high quality occupation. It was a good option that provided education, stability, potentially a source of power, and was a prestigious path to go. I think in modern times we sometimes see the church as this side organization, but in the past it was its own industry of sorts and central to life, economics, education, prestige, potentially power.
- lukebuehler 7y agoThere were and are many reasons why people became monastics. But to think that the only reasons were inheritance and property laws shows that someone only knows about monasticism from the perspective of modern medieval histories, which tend to present it this way. Not to deny that these reasons existed and made many consider monastic life as an option, but it can't be the whole story. Think about it, monastic life really was and is monastic. It included many hours of prayers and other contemplative practices (and other minor inconveniences like celibacy). Yes, there was great variance in different orders, but many people (if not most) chose this life because they were true believers. The only way to prepare them for this life was that the church as a whole was universally present so that monasticism became just one option between many different ones within the church, albeit a quite intense one.
- fit2rule 7y agoAll over the Netherlands and Germany, and Austria, old churches are being converted into homeless shelters and co-working spaces .. and clubs. I think this should be applied to the cloisters, too. I look at some of these 800 year old buildings and marvel at what they could provide, in terms of startup-hub scene.
- rpmisms 7y agoFor all those in this thread talking about monasteries without having ever been in one, please try the experience. If there's an Orthodox monastery near you, try seeing if you can stay for a few days. They generally aren't rich by any stretch of the imagination, but even staying for a few days and following the lifestyle will give you insight into why the monastic life is a valuable and valid choice in our increasingly chaotic and bombastic society. The peace you feel when in one and the sinking feeling going back into "the world" are both experiences everyone should have.
- ghostbrainalpha 7y ago3 day silent retreats completely changed my life. As someone who spent a decade in depression and near the edge of suicide, there are two things I ask people to try before killing themselves. 1) A silent retreat 2) An Ayahuasca ceremony Those two things helped more than years of therapy and anti-depressants. A pretty intense exercise regimen also helped me out a lot, but its hard to get someone to pick that over death when they are close to the edge so I don't include it.
- justaguyhere 7y agoI can understand silent retreat, could you please elaborate on Ayahuasca? I want to do it, but I am also worried a bit about the experience. Also, I am not a physically strong person, not sure if that should be a factor to consider.
- ghostbrainalpha 7y agoPhysically strength is not required at all. But you do vomit usually, so if you have some sort of intense fear of that it could be an issue. I don't believe there is anything mystical benefit to Ayahuasca, although the psychedelic element can definitely fuel your creativity if you want it to. But certain drugs appear to have long-lasting effects on mental states, even if they aren't administered daily. Ketamine is another drug that shows promise in this area. There needs to be real studies around this, but in my experience the 2 day session is highly effective for at least a year afterward.
- _pmf_ 7y agoMosques are thriving.
- neuronic 7y agoAnd this is bad how? I live in a German population center with many many mosques and it affects me in exactly zero ways. I know _no one_ who regularly visits a mosque, let alone trying to convince others to join. We have religious freedom in our constitution. Aside from some stupidly minor exceptions, Germans aren't somehow converting to Islam. They are leaving religion in general.
- basilgohar 7y agoMosques are analogous to churches, not monasteries. Even as a Muslim, I'm not sure what the Islamic equivalent for a monastery is, since monasticism it is discouraged in Islam.
- interactivecode 7y agoI guess it's difficult to manage church finances when it doesn't control government(s) anymore.
- theqult 7y agoThanks God ! /s
- gtycomb 7y agoRecently I was in India and certain circumstances connected me with a facility for the elderly run by an order of Catholic Nuns. I visited them quite a few times and while inside those closed gates there was this sense of reverence, peace, and shall I say holiness in many ways truly tangible. And when they bid me goodbye at the main gates, even as we stood there chatting a little while, the town or village people walking by outside the gates would smile and one of the sisters would call out to ask something about them. These sisters were involved with this outside world, and knew them and their needs so intimately! Yes, there is so much to understand about these areas of life us software engineering types seldom think about, it seems.
- mantoto 7y agoBy being social you mean? I also know my neighbors and I'm friendly with them.
- gtycomb 7y agomore than that, I'd say. The young auto-rikshaw man on my way to the bus station from those gates was telling me about his kidney disease and how those sisters helped raise the substantial money for a transplant ...
- mantoto 7y agoThat's called community and we as a society should try to create that without religion. Also such stories exists
- dharmach 7y agoSame investment can fetch more souls to church in India so it makes sense to invest there and not in Germany.
- paggle 7y agoBut the ARPUs in Germany will be much higher, probably enough to cancel out.
- mantoto 7y agoGood news. Those things are a really bad thing. People isolated by gender. By rules defined 1-2000 years ago and while they are taking it serious, priests don't. Yes don't forget the horrible stories of nuns sexually raped by priests! Srsly Why do you think it is a good thing to isolate yourself from modern society and think you can help while not even getting modern society anymore?!
- humble_engineer 7y agoYou are a bigot
- cat199 7y ago> not even getting modern society anymore "19 The acts of the flesh are obvious: sexual immorality, impurity and debauchery; 20 idolatry and witchcraft; hatred, discord, jealousy, fits of rage, selfish ambition, dissensions, factions 21 and envy; drunkenness, orgies, and the like. I warn you, as I did before, that those who live like this will not inherit the kingdom of God. 22 But the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, forbearance, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, 23 gentleness and self-control. Against such things there is no law. 24 Those who belong to Christ Jesus have crucified the flesh with its passions and desires. 25 Since we live by the Spirit, let us keep in step with the Spirit. 26 Let us not become conceited, provoking and envying each other." https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Galatians+5&version=NIV https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Galatians+5&ver... yep, completely out of touch & with no understanding applicable to the modern world here.
- mantoto 7y ago"The women are to keep silent in the churches; for they are not permitted to speak" And no I'm not even sure if you mean it what you wrote.
- cat199 7y agomainly that the 'problems of humanity' (e.g. ethics, morality) dealt with in christianity are period-nonspecific and have little to nothing to do with the current level of technological innovation or form of economy/government, and therefore imply that they 'get' current society.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]