4 ms·
It comes down to personality and biochemistry, not everyone is that hooked on the stuff. If you ban everything that is addictive you end up doing a disservice
by colechristensen 7y ago
It comes down to personality and biochemistry, not everyone is that hooked on the stuff.
If you ban everything that is addictive you end up doing a disservice to people who can handle the substance or item in question. Banning addictive substances because some people can't handle them goes against my philosophy of the purpose of government.
Do we need some kind of super-citizen test where you have to prove your knowledge and responsibility for people to be able to be free to do/have/use the things they want?
I don't want a nanny state that bans what it thinks is bad for me and prevents me from accessing things that I want because some people can't handle it.
I was talking to some of my old farmer relatives a few months ago and one of them was telling stories about his dynamite license. It was a useful thing to have when interacting with the land and you could get a license and just go out and buy dynamite. This was maybe 50 years ago. That is the kind of world I want to live in, where people who can prove themselves can get any tool they want or need to manipulate their minds or the world around them.
Not a world where a committee (or public pressure) can decide what I can't handle or what's too dangerous.
I don't want to live in a world of padded walls.
- leetcrew 7y agopersonally I'm with you, although I'll grant reasonable concessions (eg, not many citizens need surface-to-air missiles). the problem is ideological unfortunately. people simply don't share your definition of "freedom" or value it.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- WaxProlix 7y agoWhat's to stop research into super-heroin as a product in that world? Just come up with the most psyche-abusive substance possible and enjoy an army of essentially slaves. People with the notion that free will is some sort of absolute confuse the heck out of me. I guess sibling post is right, it's just an issue of fundamental worldview being different.
- colechristensen 7y agoThe government banning tobacco from sale is the same sort of free-will exercise by humans for humans as is me banning tobacco from my own body, just on different levels. The government can just as well have "addiction" problems with things that are bad for the population which are supported by the population. The difference isn't free-will or not, it is only the level on which it is applied. I prefer personal free will to collective free will whenever it is possible and reasonable. The purpose of government is to do things we can't do for ourselves. I can decide whether or not to use a substance which might be addictive or to abstain from it forever. The government can do that too but I really don't think they need to. They need to make sure that those kinds of products are sold pure and as expected, that there is accurate information about their usage and effects available, and that people selling them do not mislead or manipulatively hook people, but ultimately I would rather a responsible individual make decisions than a collective.
- Faark 7y agoNotably absent in your list is to incentivize the "right" behavior, especially when society will have to pay for it down the line via social safety nets. Hopefully less of an issue with vaping.
- colechristensen 7y agoCorrect, I do not want the government to be a moral guide. I want the government to promote what is true, not what is right.
- fcarraldo 7y agoI can’t get behind this argument when we live in an economy driven by a massive industry of personalized marketing and advertising. You espouse free will as if it’s some absolute, but studies show that human behavior is primarily the product of environment and is, to an extent, easy to predict the likelihood of someone becoming a smoker based on their age, race, income and zip code. How can we justify giving mega corporations carte blanche to market poisonous and addictive substance to our own friends, family and neighbors without asking that the government step in to prevent it?
- deepVoid 7y agoSmoking and Juul hurt public health more than anything else. Not only the smokers themselves get lunge disease or even die, but also other innocent second-hand smokers get hurt. I do not want my little kids' lungs to absorb smoke just because they are playing in public. Smoking and Juul are universally bad with little or no benefits. They should be banned from any public space for good.
- colechristensen 7y agoThis kind of paranoia about exposure goes way too far beyond trying to prevent actual negative consequences to a fanatical obsession with one irritant out of a million which is way below the noise floor. If you want to live in a HEPA bubble, live in a HEPA bubble. Outside isn't that.
- ThrustVectoring 7y agoThis isn't legal advice, but a lot of the restrictions around buying and using explosives on your own land for personal purposes is waived for binary explosives. You can go and buy tannerite, mix it on-site, and use it as an explosive firearms target and blow stuff up. Zero licensing required to do this. NB: Do not do this if you have a felony conviction since this that makes it a crime.
- colechristensen 7y agoI just read Ignition! so I have lots of ideas about doing irresponsible things which are fundamentally incompatible with a Mountain View apartment. Converting a bit of a cornfield into a rocket test stand is a reasonable thing to do, right? But if anyone wants a remote employee in a central time zone moving back to the family farm so I have a few hundred acres to screw around with instead of about 20 sq ft...
- souprock 7y agoIf a different farm would do, my workplace is about 20 to 30 minutes away from an area where you could buy about 10 acres without trouble. It's low-level hacking, in Florida, a few dozen miles south of Cape Canaveral: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19797601 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19797601
- sudosteph 7y agoI'm sure all the employers on HN are just chomping at the bit to have you on their company health insurance plan after that post :P But on a more serious note, if you're considering the remote work life, I do recommend it.
- colechristensen 7y agoI did about three years of remote work, I have mixed feelings about it, really depends a lot of the environment.
- ThrustVectoring 7y ago
- paulcole 7y ago> I don't want a nanny state that bans what it thinks is bad for me and prevents me from accessing things that I want because some people can't handle it. Show me a one-armed guy who bought a stick of dynamite thinking, “No way can I handle this.”