5 ms·
> For those saying publishers should do first party ads, that would lose them most of their income Yes? Does that make it less likely? Less needed? No If publ
by alkonaut 7y ago
> For those saying publishers should do first party ads, that would lose them most of their income
Yes? Does that make it less likely? Less needed? No
If publishers can buy targeted ads with fraud detection, they will. But when they can’t (because the idea of the auctioned third party js blob finally dies) there will be money in dumber ads.
What might happen of course is that if someone wants to spend $X on ads that are dumb and untargeted they might as well buy a spot on the side of a bus. Do there would be a flow of ad money back from the web to traditional advertising.
- manigandham 7y agoAds are not going to become dumb. They're going to become privacy-compliant and more secure. Some signals will go away while others are replaced, but we're not suddenly going back to ads on the sides of buses.
- JohnFen 7y ago> They're going to become privacy-compliant I'm not so confident about this. At least, I haven't seen any serious efforts (or even proposals) from the industry in that direction.
- manigandham 7y agoTransparency and Consent Framework (now v2): https://iabeurope.eu/policy/introducing-for-public-comment-transparency-and-consent-framework-tcf-version-2-0/ https://iabeurope.eu/policy/introducing-for-public-comment-t... Privolta (our startup for 1st-party privacy-safe ads): https://www.privolta.com/ https://www.privolta.com/ There are many others. Regulation always creates opportunity.
- JohnFen 7y agoI'm aware of the TCF, but it doesn't really address what I'm talking about. I couldn't find any real information about what Privolta is doing on the website, so can't comment on that. What I have been seeing out of the industry (primarily what the IAB has been talking about and Google's "privacy sandbox") doesn't rise to the level of protecting privacy yet. Perhaps someday, but right now what it looks like is that they're seeking ways to continue an inherently privacy-invading business model while minimizing the impact of potential regulation.
- manigandham 7y agoShort summary: ID generation based on regulations and consent. Random number or cohort sample. Local data only, send and received interests matrix and ad payload while decisions happen locally. Plenty of ways to provide most targeting capabilities without revealing a particular user, until they decide to convert as a customer.
- JohnFen 7y agoAll I ask for is that my informed consent is obtained before data is collected (and data is not collected if I refuse to provide consent). If that bar is met, then I have no further objections. But, and this is an honest question, where are the actual proposals to require that?
- manigandham 7y agoThat's what the "C" in TCF stands for. Consent management platforms are an entire new sub-industry in adtech for displaying, gathering, and managing user consent for vendors. The proposals are the implementation. The enforcement comes from regulation.
- JohnFen 7y agoYes, I know. The TCF is a technical infrastructure, and as such doesn't address my concern. It only comes into play if the industry actually starts taking informed consent seriously. That's the part that I'm doubting. > The enforcement comes from regulation. Indeed. It appears that strong legislation is the only realistic solution -- but that seems doubtful to me as well, since the big players have been, and will likely continue, working as hard as they can to ensure that any legislation will be token at best.
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> Do there would be a flow of ad money back from the web to traditional advertising. That's not an improvement, because manipulating matter involves using up more resources. For all their problems, on-line ads harm the climate less. That said, I of course welcome anything that can roll back the current state of on-line advertising. Even dumb on-line ads would still be more profitable than physical ones, and since advertising is a zero sum game, I don't expect the publishers to really lose money on that.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]