4 ms·
But won't somebody think of the poor businesses who'll surely be driven to ruin if they can't track my every step? These people keep shitting in the well, and
by pavel_lishin 7y ago
But won't somebody think of the poor businesses who'll surely be driven to ruin if they can't track my every step?
These people keep shitting in the well, and yelling at us for buying bottled water.
- mrspeaker 7y agoI think if the next few years are going to be entertaining. At the moment a handful of shitty companies are abusing their ability to track users - but for me (and I think for many non profit-affected nerds) the outcome seems clear: ANY AND ALL third-party script have to go. Even when that means losing all the third-party goodness (CDNs, analytics, cloud providers...) that we've come to depend on. Yep, they save an uncountable amount of time and effort - but at the cost of tracking users' every step... We can't have one without the other!
- tgsovlerkhgsel 7y agoThird-party should not be the qualifier here. Cloudflare's CDNJS sets, by default, crossorigin=anonymous and subresource integrity. Add a "Referrer-Policy: no-referrer" header, and all the CDN sees is either a) nothing, because the client has the resource cached or b) a request for a certain version of jQuery without knowing where it came from. If you think this is a good idea because it enables technical enforcement, do you also want to ban static.example.com? Because if you don't, you'll soon have pointstothirdpartyadserver.example.com. If you do, you'll have https://example.com/proxytothirdpartyadserver/ https://example.com/proxytothirdpartyadserver/ instead... This is not a problem that can be completely solved on a technical level. Enforce the hell out of GDPR and see the problem shrink.
- jraph 7y agoIt sounds like mitigating the CDN problem could be done like what the Decentraleyes browser addon does: replacing CDN hosted files by local versions. What are the difficulties for a browser to provide such a feature by default?
- tgsovlerkhgsel 7y agoYou need to decide which CDN files to ship locally, you need to store them, do the initial fetching, etc. There is already a system for all of that. It's called the browser cache.
- tjoff 7y agoThere is nothing inherent in any of those that require tracking. Nor scripts that run in the browser.
- JaggedNZ 7y agoHonestly, if all third party scripts are blocked, the ad networks will just start making their participant sites serve the javascript direct and/or run local applications to proxy the data back to them. And unfortunately most management will force the changes through, because they want in on that ad revenue gravy train.
- hermanradtke 7y agoThis is much harder to do, especially in larger enterprises where changes can take months. This includes updates and bug fixes. If this is where we push the industry, it will be a huge win for users.
- Doxin 7y agoI'm willing to bet that IF this happens it'll amount to a lot of companies just including something like this on every page: <?PHP echo(file_get_contents("http://google.com/nefarious_crap.html")); ?>
- artificial 7y agoCorrect, one method is via a subdomain to serve the 3rd party through. Bummer is when it’s mixed with data so blocking it isn’t as straight forward.
- XCSme 7y agoThe ad networks only satisfy the market demand. Makes sense that if you are an ad publisher that you want to get the best ROI on your ad budget, so if you can choose between two ad networks, one of which shows your ads to random users and another one which shows your ads only to your target audience, while having the same cost per impression, you will choose the one that brings you most revenue. Business don't care how those "target audiences" were created, but they want access to them.
- quicklime 7y agoIs it not possible to create an ad network that only supports static targeted ads? The ad network itself can run its own JavaScript, but I don't see any reason to allow the advertisers themselves to run scripts inside ads, other than to make the ad look a bit flashier and interactive.
- zeta0134 7y agoIt's perfectly possible. The problem is that these very scripts the ad network are serving are what people are objecting to. Exactly these scripts, and exactly this tracking. It creeps people out.
- XCSme 7y agoI think the best solution so far is for advertisers to just purchase banners on the sites their target audience is on, just like in the old days. Maybe use something like BuySellAds to find and buy "directly" from that niche site, but BSA is pretty bad.
- pavel_lishin 7y ago> The ad networks only satisfy the market demand. I could not give less of a shit about justification of bad behavior by invoking market demand, if it leads to me finding a turd in my drinking water. Unless, of course, it leads to the dawning of understanding that maybe the Econ-101 understanding of supply-and-demand is a spherical-cow level of analogy that rapidly breaks down when it encounters the real world, and that regulation isn't a toxin.