6 ms·
Another reminder that bad press and community/customer pressure indeed works. And there's nothing wrong with that.
by minimaxir 7y ago
Another reminder that bad press and community/customer pressure indeed works. And there's nothing wrong with that.
- qsymmachus 7y agoDirect action gets the goods!
- endianswap 7y agoEh, maybe? It "worked" in that they're choosing to not renew the contracts over the next year, but he admitted that over the last year employees have been fighting for this and have been ignored until now, which is pretty shitty. For revenue that appears to be only $95k USD (the amount they're earning from the contract that they're instead going to match to charity)? https://twitter.com/DannyPage/status/1176155955173552133 https://twitter.com/DannyPage/status/1176155955173552133
- floatingatoll 7y agoThere are two ways to get something right: 1) The first time 2) Later than that They did the second. It’s sucks that it isn’t the first, and it sucks that they didn’t pick the right horse during the race up until this point. But they changed their mind, openly and in plainly spoken terms. “Worked” doesn’t need a qualifier here. Their failure to implement #1 correctly, and their pivot to implement #2, will help them serve as a lesson to others.
- dredmorbius 7y agoAlso: 1. Insufficiently. 2. Sufficiently. The question is on this aspect.
- krainboltgreene 7y ago> They did the second. No, I disagree. What they have done is literally the minimum amount of effort. The right thing to do is not to "continue to do what we're doing, offering a passive promise to not get more money."
- floatingatoll 7y agoWhat is the right thing to do?
- krainboltgreene 7y agoResign and cancel the contract.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoIt just means someone else is going to pick that contract up. Disclaimer: I bid on federal gov projects. The work is fairly fungible.
- ianleeclark 7y agoThis isn't a bad thing. It's an action that will cause retooling and any of the associated costs to happen when they otherwise wouldn't. Let them pick the contract up. Hopefully they charge more, take longer to implement, and are generally worse.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoNot only does this have little impact to ICE, the taxpayer gets soaked. Expensive outrage porn.
- kevinmgranger 7y agoThe more expensive it is to operate ICE, the harder it is to justify its continued operation.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoThe project is worth ~$100k-$200k. It’s a rounding error in their budget (ICE annual budget is about $8 billion a year for FY2018; for context, US DHS is ~$92 billion/yr) No one is ever going to deprecate ICE because it’s too expensive. They’ll just pull the money from someplace like NASA (unfortunate reality, not a policy I endorse).
- ezrast 7y agoSo it's a rounding error for DHS but an expensive soaking for the taxpayer? That doesn't bear out. No one is going to deprecate ICE because it's too expensive, but they might do it due to extensive political pressure from all sectors. I'm okay with paying 0.001 USD or so to send that message.
- swsieber 7y agoI have mixed feelings. It was basically a mob-driven decision. Mob made decisions can have good or bad outcomes, but the action being pressured for by mobs is usually irrational. I think there's something to be said for listening to your customers and community. But how much of the pushback was from the community? Certainly the developer who yanked their code. And from what I've read the internal developers too. But I think having to fear crowds of probably less than completely informed people generally lacking nuance is not something to be lauded.
- floatingatoll 7y agoDo you consider the specific action requested by the mob in this specific instance to be irrational?
- swsieber 7y agoI'm honestly not sure. Other people will take up the up the contract, and the work will get done, but probably not quite as cheaply.
- freen 7y agoOther people can choose to enable evil: it's their moral failure.
- dragonwriter 7y agoIf evil is more expensive, it will be harder for evil doers to get as much of it done.
- swsieber 7y agoSo yeah, I say "I'm not sure" because I don't know the personal motives of the individual outspoken people. It really depends on what they thought it was going to accomplish, and why they wanted those things to happen. Thwarting ICE? Incredibly unlikely and impractical . Slowing ICE down? Probably.