3 ms·
> The Aware Home, like many other visionary projects, imagined a digital future that empowers individuals to lead more-effective lives. What is most critical is
by ryandrake 7y ago
> The Aware Home, like many other visionary projects, imagined a digital future that empowers individuals to lead more-effective lives. What is most critical is that in the year 2000 this vision naturally assumed an unwavering commitment to the privacy of individual experience.
We used to have fairly decent home automation products back then (wow, 20 years ago!) Even the cheap consumer X10 stuff at least worked and could even be used without a LAN, let alone Internet. Since then, the products have actually gotten worse in many ways. Sure, sensors are a little smaller now, and some of the designs look less dorky. On the other hand, it seems everything phones home (or elsewhere) now, stops working without Internet, exposes you to a massively increased computer security risk, and/or is stuffed with ads.
Look for a decent home security camera that doesn't 1. Store video in the cloud, 2. Send opaque binary data back to some server in China, 3. Require an internet connection to set up, administer, or use, 4. Come with a giant EULA, Terms of Use & Privacy Policy. They exist but you need to dig a bit to find them.
I used to only think about keeping people out of my home LAN, limiting/blocking incoming connections, preventing infiltration, having an “Internet only” guest VLAN. Now it’s just as important to block outgoing connections and prevent data exfiltration. You need a “no Internet” VLAN to isolate your “smart” devices. I used to be terrified to see all the failed login attempts on my internet-addressable SSH server. Now I’m terrified to see all the outgoing connection attempts from all my various devices and proprietary software.
A lightbulb shouldn’t need a Privacy Policy. We stopped improving the Aware Home and instead added the Connected Home. Bad exchange.
- mfer 7y agoThe goal used to be academic and early innovators trying to improve the home. The goal posts have changed. It's not about making huge companies lots of money and helping them gain power and influence. This isn't a technological shift as much as it's a goal shift.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoIt's a good reason to reject those companies and encourage everyone else we know to reject them too.
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoThere are still technologies that work like X10 did today, a lot more reliably. Insteon and Z-Wave are both still very solid RF-based home automation platforms. Plenty of IP cameras come without the default assumption of cloud use, though it's ideal to VLAN off anything that you aren't super confident in the security of.
- JohnFen 7y agoAgreed -- but that tech still exists. Funny story, last week I was telling a coworker about how I had fully automated my home back around 1995. He was genuinely surprised that this was possible before "the internet of things". I had to inform him that the only difference between the tech of today and the tech then is that today's tech is smaller and cheaper, and the only difference between "automation" and "internet of things" is that the latter involves being subjected to surveillance. But he's a young sprout and has no living memory of the state of things back then.