4 ms·
As an American transplant to Amsterdam, here's my take: The Dutch have embedded innovation/entrepreneurship so deeply into their society, it looks very differe
by dr_dshiv 7y ago
As an American transplant to Amsterdam, here's my take:
The Dutch have embedded innovation/entrepreneurship so deeply into their society, it looks very different from American-style innovation. There are so many little innovative things here that startups would never get to. It is continuous, but not relentless -- as in, it occurs within the paradigm of working hours. Further, it tends to reflect the systemic intelligence of organizations, at a large and small scale.
Example Domains:
Transportation (all aspects), payment (online and off), festivals (incredibly innovative!), road construction, garbage pickup (yes! It's so futuristic!), child care & education, psychology, medicine...
In any of these areas, I can readily think of smart innovations that would impress Americans. The innovations are not of the "Uber for X", digital startup-based type. So, seeing the lack of Dutch statups in VC portfolios might suggest a less innovative culture. Here, entrepreneurship often occurs within the context of existing systems and organizations. It's a different, complementary way to think about things -- I rather like it.
Also, there are only 17 million people in the Netherlands. It's a much smaller market and startups that successfully capture this market don't necessarily transfer to external markets.
Further, when things are working really well, there isn't always a need for disruption... Nevertheless, things in the Netherlands never seem "done". Sure, there is great transportation, healthcare and education -- but that's because they are always ripping it up and building the future of it. Sometimes in the States, things can seem like we are just trying to keep the status quo from falling apart too badly.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mcv 7y ago> "garbage pickup (yes! It's so futuristic!)" Is our garbage pickup futuristic? It's certainly efficient and practical (which are probably the most important and most typically Dutch values), but there's nothing about underground containers that's out of reach for other countries. I think much of our innovation and efficiency is actually in government organisations, from garbage pickup to our efficient and well-maintained infrastructure (you really notice the road quality drop when you cross the border with Belgium or Germany), to our 'polder model': talks between government, employers and labour unions to decide on employment standards that everybody can agree to so we won't have any strikes. It's true that we don't have the kind of startup culture that California has, despite attempts from the government. I'm not sure why, but then again, even in the 17th century, our big innovation was the invention of the multinational, globe-spanning corporation, not the small startup. And a big part of the innovation there was not so much the risk taken, but the way those risks were mitigated: financial products that spread the risk around. Many ships at the time were funded were funded through a system of life insurance.
- vidarh 7y ago> It's true that we don't have the kind of startup culture that California has, despite attempts from the government. Consider the sheer amount of government funding it took for Silicon Valley to become possible, before any other factors. Among other factors it took decades of massive military funding for the radio and semiconductor industry to lay the foundation and attract the talent that would later branch out. The biggest barrier to replicating this is government willingness to pour that kind of money into tech in a single area.
- mercer 7y ago> It's true that we don't have the kind of startup culture that California has, despite attempts from the government. I've been part of an Amsterdam startup and 'started' my own companies with various people a few times, and my impression is that there are a few reasons for this: 1. much as it's easy to start a company, it seems difficult to get funding. The government seems to be trying, but it still feels less than what I read about SV (or at least SV in the past?). 2. the market is much smaller. once you need to deal with other countries with other languages, (tax) regulations that are often much more complicated and bureaucratic, cultural differences, etc., things get much more difficult, and I've noticed multiple small startups around here just don't bother. 3. for tech startup type workers at least, but probably for most workers here, there's less of a culture of jumping into a startup. we like our steady jobs, we are quick to complain about overwork, and there's all sorts of (good) protections that possibly make it more difficult to find employees and grow. In regards to 3, the startup I worked for consisted of a just-out-of-school programmer, a wealthy-and-connected but inexperienced CEO, and a fantastic and experienced designer who, in his forties, decided to do something 'risky' and 'new'. He also came from wealth but had done very well for himself too. and later a social media/marketing person who was just out of college. So the startup either involved people who could put it on their CV regardless of how well things went, or people who could afford faffing about for a while. I suppose I was in the latter camp, although that's more because I just don't spend much money and make enough as a front-ender currently that I can do 'cool' things without much skin in the game.
- dr_dshiv 7y agoTrashmen collecting garbage with an Xbox controller and giant claw? In a neon jumpsuit? Yes. That's futuristic. I hope NYC adopts the system. I agree, it is totally within reach.