2 ms·
I disagree, you can argue the semantics of if it's him specifically or if it's another project that decides it will only target systemd/pulseaudio. But the fact
by dijit 7y ago
I disagree, you can argue the semantics of if it's him specifically or if it's another project that decides it will only target systemd/pulseaudio. But the fact that if I want a stable distro for server usage in 2019 I _must_ use a systemd distro speaks to the fact that I am indeed forced to use it.
Maybe that's just adoption though, typically the sysadmin community considers the "safe" options to be CentOS/RHEL or Debian Stable. Both of which default to systemd. (and no sysadmin is going to change the init system on production servers unless it presents some abject nightmare, short of eating 30% CPU/Mem-- it's core software, it wont be touched).
Projects like Devuan are simply not considered safe choices by the majority of the sysadmin community, and there's no alternative for RHEL-esque sites.
So, semantically: it's not poetterings fault. But at the same time, I'm still forced.
- emmelaich 7y agoSorry, but you'll need to find a word different from "forced"
- dijit 7y agoWhat word would you recommend? If I must do something then I am forced? no? -- and I'm not being facetious I'm genuinely curious. If I wish to keep using production grade linux distributions (that my company has been using for 15+ years) then I must adopt systemd. I guess I could convince my 25,000+ person organisation to change everything to a Debian based OS and subsequently move them to Debian, but that's not likely.
- westurner 7y agoWhy do you think that is? Why have production grade Linux distributions all chosen to adopt systemd? With SysV init, how do you securely launch processes in cgroups, such that they'll consistently restart when the process happens to terminate, with stdout and stderr logged with consistent timestamps, with process dependency models that allow for faster boots due to parallelization? (edit) Journalctl is far better than `tail -f /var/log/starstar` and parsing all of those timestamps and inconsistently escaped logfile formats. There's no good way to modify everything in /etc/init.d in order to log to syslog-ng or rsyslog. Systemd and journalctl solve for that; for unified logging. IMO, there's no question that systemd is the better way and I have zero nostalgia for spawning everything from a probably a shell specified in an /etc/init.d shebang without process restarting (and logging thereof), cgroups, and consistent logging.
- regularfry 7y ago> With SysV init Why is sysvinit presented as the only alternative to systemd-consume-the-world? It's not, and it never was.
- dijit 7y agoThis is a bit of a loaded question, but to directly answer the point: RHEL adopted systemd because it developed systemd. Specifically for its use-cases, it was initially deployed on Fedora, where I used it myself (because I was and am a fan of fedora). Debian adopted after having internal discussions[0] which are public record. To summarise their discussion (a little bit flippantly, I agree) would be to say that they adopted it because it was becoming the de-facto standard already and a lot of other projects wanted to use features only available in SystemD. [0]: https://wiki.debian.org/Debate/initsystem/systemd https://wiki.debian.org/Debate/initsystem/systemd
- throw0101a 7y ago> Why do you think that is? Why have production grade Linux distributions all chosen to adopt systemd? Because RH funds a lot of software development, and Poettering works for them. > Journalctl is far better than `tail -f /var/log/starstar` Except when journald shits the bed and corrupts its own log file. Or when you want ship logs off-machine, yet journald does not support any standards-compliant transport so you end up have to log a second logging daemon (e.g., rsyslog)—in which case what's the damn point of the first? Or when you do a "service mysql start" and it dies, but there is no output anywhere of what went wrong, and you have to guess that you have a typo in your "my.cnf". But other than that Mrs. Lincoln, how was the play? > ... in an /etc/init.d shebang without process restarting (and logging thereof), cgroups, and consistent logging. The problem is not systemd-as-init-replacement. The problem is systemd-as-kitchen-sink. udevd is an "essential" part of systemd? Really? It can't be it's own stand-alone project? Really?
- bscphil 7y ago> Or when you do a "service mysql start" and it dies, but there is no output anywhere of what went wrong, and you have to guess that you have a typo in your "my.cnf". First of all, it's systemctl you want, not service. Service is (was) part of Upstart, which Ubuntu doesn't officially use any more but they still have a bunch of compatibility layers in for it. Second, do the following not give you the information you need? systemctl status unit-name journalctl -u unit-name
- wsy 7y agoAfter consideration, you decided that even though you don't like systemd, using a distro with it is the better deal than all other available options, such as moving to Debian. It still seems to be the best trade-off for you. You don't use it because you are forced, you use it because you get value from it.
- afthonos 7y agoPerhaps a less loaded way is to say GP uses it because a distribution they find value in finds value in it. It’s not “forcing”, but neither is it entirely their choice. It’s possible replacing systemd would be a net gain for them.
- massysett 7y agoYou can use a BSD or Slackware.
- dijit 7y agoLucky me! (although genuinely we did make the backends to one of our games FreeBSD, but its a lot more awkward to use than something like Debian on google cloud, and don't get me started on ZFS performance on Google Cloud, it's abysmal)
- enriquto 7y agoalso voidlinux
- bscphil 7y agoOr Alpine Linux. I believe it's already one of the best-regarded distributions for the container space, and it uses OpenRC, not systemd.
- hollerith 7y agoOK, but aren't most Alpine instances running in containers hosted by Linux instances using systemd?
- yjftsjthsd-h 7y agoThat doesn't mean it doesn't work fine as the base layer. I run Alpine on bare metal... actually, I really like Alpine as the thing that hosts KVM and/or Docker, too.
- Vinnl 7y agoYou could argue that you are forced to use it, but you cannot really argue that Poettering was the one that's doing the forcing, I think.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]