4 ms·
Fill in time: > unless the effective probe launch time is greater than 270 million years, the galaxy is old enough for every system to have been settled
by nabla9 7y ago
Fill in time:
> unless the effective probe launch time is greater than 270 million years, the galaxy is old enough for every system to have been settled from an initial single civilization
Conclusions:
> When diffusive stellar motions are accounted for,they contribute to the Galaxy becoming fully settled in a time less than, or at very least comparable to its present age, even for slow or infrequent interstellar probes.
>While settlement wave crossing and fill-in times are short, consideration of finite civilization lifetimes in a steady state model allows for conditions in which the settled fraction X is less than 1. Thus the galaxy may be in a steady state in which not every settleable system is currently settled.
Conclusion basically says that if there are expanding civilizations in our galaxy, they spread very slowly, have filled the galaxy sparsely or have limited lifetimes. Assuming they are not avoiding contact.
- johnchristopher 7y agoWhat if we are the probe and we haven't figured it out yet ? Or what if we somehow didn't get the memo telling everyone to stay hidden because of danger, because we are late to the party ? What if there's a natural/alien occurring culling of some kind and we somehow slipped through and now we are alone ? ^^
- trumbitta2 7y ago> What if there's a natural/alien occurring culling of some kind and we somehow slipped through and now we are alone ? Mass Effect Reapers, anyone?
- dvdkhlng 7y agoSee also the Zoo Hypothesis [1] :) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zoo_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zoo_hypothesis
- nirui 7y ago> What if there's a natural/alien occurring culling of some kind and we somehow slipped through and now we are alone? Guess that one of the benefits of living in suburbs[1]. 1: https://imagine.gsfc.nasa.gov/science/objects/milkyway1.html https://imagine.gsfc.nasa.gov/science/objects/milkyway1.html Back to the topic. Let's assume there is a space nomad nazi species out there right now, will that species survive long enough to conquer the entire galaxy?
- has2k1 7y ago> What if there's a natural/alien occurring culling of some kind and we somehow slipped through and now we are alone ? You are referring to what is known as "The Great Filter". The more troubling question is, What if we are alone because all the more advanced civilizations have been culled?
- kiliantics 7y agoclimate change certainly looks to be a very likely contender for a filter
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- m4rtink 7y agoHiding does not look like a good countermeassure for a culling, as rapid expansion as possible seems much better & possibly good solution overall as long as the resulting human civilisation does not end up to be the one that does the culling.
- dvdkhlng 7y agoI wonder whether due to the anthropic principle [1], assuming a (practically) infinite number of different universes exist, the likelhood of being the only sentient species in the whole universe is significant higher than the alternative? I.e. the number of universes that are incapable of harboring life is many order of magnitudes larger than the number of universes that may accidentally harbor life (i.e. us) which is still many order of magnitudes larger than the number of universes that actually have a more realistic chance of harbouring life. So us being a singular "accident" may just be a likely consequence of being here and asking questions. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthropic_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthropic_principle [update] see also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fine-tuned_universe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fine-tuned_universe
- psychoslave 7y agoFrankly, I don't understand how this autocentric posture can resist any serious enquiry. To my mind it seems alarmingly full of causal vicious circles, and lake any clear way to be invalidated experimentally. In particular, taking the "number of possible universes" seems problematic to me, as we can only obverse the one in which we interact. And even taking that for granted, what is so astonishing that the actual one is the one that is compatible with our existence? I mean, if any possible universe could have happened, then the one we live in had actually an equal chance to exist with any other. Since this perspective assume that at least one universe must actualize, then pure randomness by drawing of lots is enough to explain the result. No need for a teleological purpose. Apply Law of Parsimony and you are done: Anthropic principle add needless ad hoc assumptions to reach its predetermined conclusions, especially in its strong version. Also, the anthropic principle stands on many assumptions, including that the simulated models of tweaked universes do reflect other conceivable world in a fiddle manner would they be actual things. It also neglects that among an infinity of variation, you surely should be able to come with totally different forms of "life". That is, for example it takes life as a carbon based structure, so you need universes with constant tweaked for enabling star to produce and disseminate carbon before they collapse. But on the counterpart, it can't pretend if you take it seriously, that other universes could not have produced very different form of "life". To my mind, we have no idea if our current actual universe is not also populated with non-carbon based life form. Also this kind of theory emphases greatly on what the world did allowed with these tweaking. But, among an infinity of other combinations, who would seriously consider that nothing better could have been produced than a mankind tormented in wars and questions which are at best extremely hard to solve for its limited cognitive abilities, if not definitely out of its reach?