5 ms·
The gift card market just confuses me. Especially when it's people giving gifts to people (not corporate gifts), cash is something that has at least as much val
by dehrmann 7y ago
The gift card market just confuses me. Especially when it's people giving gifts to people (not corporate gifts), cash is something that has at least as much value as the gift card, is accept everywhere, isn't a liability on a balance sheet, and is easier to give.
- Scarblac 7y agoIdeally a gift should show that you know the other person well enough to pick just the right thing for them. Money is the other extreme, it says "I really have no idea what kind of gift you'd like", so apparently you hardly know each other. Gift cards are at least a small step up, you show you think the other likes to travel.
- onion2k 7y agoCash with a note saying "For you to enjoy in <person's favourite shop>" then.
- why-oh-why 7y agoThat reminds me of my grandma, she used to hand me money “for you to buy some X” I should give her a call.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoI wonder whether this sentiment evolved naturally, or was created by merchants (the way we have an ever growing amount of holidays and customs that somehow oblige you to spend lots of money). On the one hand, giving a well-received physical gift shows that you know the person enough to get them something they wanted. On the other hand, it also risks they'll have an unplanned item that kind-of-but-not-quite matches what they actually wanted, creating friction and inconvenience in their lives. I know this is a custom, but personally, I'd much prefer to get a monetary equivalent instead. (One custom in my area I know where giving actual money is still expected is weddings. This is usually justified by the fact that organizing a wedding costs a ton of money, so this helps the newlyweds recoup the expense.)
- viraptor 7y agoSame, I really don't get gift cards as actual gifts. On the other hand, because they're less useful than money, you can often get them cheaper in some kind of promotion. I'm getting almost all of my groceries+fuel via gift cards which I can get from my car insurer with 5% discount. But there are many online markets that would probably give a better price of you have time to deal with them.
- Jaruzel 7y agoThe thing about 'gift cards' is that people think they are money. They are not, they hold no actual monetary value, which is why you can't request the issuing company to convert them back to cash. Also MANY gift cards have expiry dates on them. It doesn't matter if the gift card is 'worth' £3,000, if it's past its expiry date, that £3,000 is effectively gone.
- Erwin 7y agoThere's one online alcohol retailer that will actually give you 5% on any gift cards you buy -- and they never expire: https://www.masterofmalt.com/gift-vouchers/ https://www.masterofmalt.com/gift-vouchers/