3 ms·
It's funny to think that pushing 196gbps is possibly just as little as ~8000 simultaneous streams. Also a shame that it is TLS'd. The content already has its
by mlyle 7y ago
It's funny to think that pushing 196gbps is possibly just as little as ~8000 simultaneous streams.
Also a shame that it is TLS'd. The content already has its own DRM/encryption.
- nine_k 7y agoTLS plays a different role. It makes sure you're receiving the Netflix's DRMed and encrypted content, and not some MITMed content that also happens to be correctly DRMed and encrypted, but contains something else.
- mlyle 7y agoEasy enough to make the content authenticate itself, instead of repeating cryptographic work for each viewer. E.g. every 64k block contains a SHA256 hash of the next 64k block. When a user seeks, you provide the hash of the first block they'll be receiving over a trusted channel. (It already can exist at start of stream RSA signed or whatever). But that's probably a pain when you have so many different devices to support. (It also makes it harder to figure out what content people are watching... Though I think they use variable bitrate encoding which will fall to traffic analysis).
- im3w1l 7y agoThis exists in a more advanced form already https://wicg.github.io/webpackage/draft-yasskin-http-origin-signed-responses.html https://wicg.github.io/webpackage/draft-yasskin-http-origin-...
- mlyle 7y agoNo... it's not the same as signed HTTP exchanges, which you'd generally use inside TLS, and involves signing all of the data in an exchange. It wouldn't work very well for streaming, either. The important feature of the scheme that I mentioned is that there's no per-client encryption needed, except maybe a small operation on each client seek in the stream. In general, you just serve the file, and the file contents are self-authenticating against tampering. You might use signed HTTP exchanges to push the first hash in the chain on a seek, I guess. Or just run it over TLS. Or just have a 64k block pre-signed at the beginning stream with the hashes of 2k chosen seek points that the client can store.
- emaste 7y agoTLS keeps your viewing history private from third parties (e.g. your ISP).
- yardstick 7y agoWhat’s the problem with TLS? The performance overhead of it is minimal these days.
- toast0 7y agoIt depends on the application; but for bulk transit of already encrypted (presumably by DRM) data, it is a significant overhead for little value. You can go back and look at Netflix presentations from when they switched to TLS, and they were no longer able to saturate their network cards (and here, they're at 50% on network still)