2 ms·
For once, rather than take apart the naive philosophy of the teleporter clone nonsense, I'm going to get pedantic about the rules of Star Trek lore. The transp
by AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y ago
For once, rather than take apart the naive philosophy of the teleporter clone nonsense, I'm going to get pedantic about the rules of Star Trek lore.
The transporter does not create a clone. This is explicitly stated to not be the way transporters work in Second Chances (TNG). In that episode, it is considered a very unusual phenomena that there is a second Riker specifically because transporters don't work that way. All LaForge can offer is supposition.
Of course, Star Trek has always played fast and loose with its own technology's mechanics, so this may be contradicted by episodes I'm not currently recalling.
- Jaruzel 7y agoFrom my memories of reading the Trek Technical Manual: 1. The transporter blows you apart at the atomic level. 2. It then encodes all your atomic information into the transporter buffer. The buffer is a massive storage array (even for trek tech) but only has a limited lifespan (see: Relics, TNG). 3. The data in the buffer is then streamed over an 'energy beam' carrier to the destination location. 4. At the destination the atomic information is rebuilt into a new 'you'. Right down to what your synapses were doing at the time of step #1. ... In the way that a jigsaw is still the same jigsaw no matter how many times you take it apart and rebuild it, the theory is that it's not a clone of you, as the original never exists at the same time the 'clone' does. The above steps totally ignore the implausibility of being able to rebuild the subject at the other end, without any infrastructure. Transporter-pad to transporter-pad transfers make logical sense, but transporter-pad to anywhere-on-a-planet... not so much.