2 ms·
I'm not sure "debunks" is the word here, because reading that meta-analysis doesn't get me very far. There's not much to it other than a simple table and it's
by skybrian 7y ago
I'm not sure "debunks" is the word here, because reading that meta-analysis doesn't get me very far.
There's not much to it other than a simple table and it's hard to interpret. What is "global warming potential" and "total energy use"? In the studies that say recycling is better, on what grounds do they conclude that, and are the conditions they're assuming realistic?
The next step would be reading the individual studies and figuring out how they work, which is more than I'm going to do for a casual Internet conversation. The links and references would be a good starting point for someone willing to do the work, though.
And to answer your question, sharing links is generally pretty useful for people who want to dig deeper, and we should do more of it.