10 ms·
So if I can't afford to buy my own high-end computer, I have to use one of the loaners from work. And those loaners won't be anywhere near as nice as the ones
by wccrawford 16y ago
So if I can't afford to buy my own high-end computer, I have to use one of the loaners from work. And those loaners won't be anywhere near as nice as the ones that people have bought.
So now my job performance depends on how much money I'm willing to spend on products that are for the company's benefit. If I'm not willing to cough up enough dough, I won't get good reviews or raises. I might even be fired for under-performing!
Yeah, this sounds like a great idea... If you want to invite lawsuits.
Having said that, I bring my own mouse and keyboard to work. I didn't ask, I just did it. The comfort was worth more to me than it was to them, apparently.
- adestefan 16y agoMost tradesmen are required to provide their own tools. I can see the arguments about security holding this back, but it's not an unprecedented idea.
- crander 16y agoTools for developers and designers is a big point. Especially with new hires. Ten years ago joining a major corporation gave you access to resources you didn't have on your own. Exchange was better than Yahoo mail. The T20 cost so much almost no one would buy it for personal use. Today when student graduate they are often used to and already own Mac laptops or high-end PCs and are using Google services. They can lose productivity going from these (cloud) consumer to enterprise technology systems. I recommend the Gartner report "Gartner_Report_BYOC_checklist.pdf" on BYOC.
- sliverstorm 16y agoIndeed, and if your job actually requires a high-end computer you're probably getting paid well enough to afford one.
- gaius 16y agoThat's simply not true in graphic design, DTP, 3D modelling, etc.
- joeguilmette 16y agoOr in any job where mobility is desirable. A good laptop is not cheap.
- sudont 16y agoMost tradesmen have leeway in buying the tools that suit them best. This doesn't work in a corporation, as the amount of work IT would have to do to support every different computer that wanders in would be insane. Look at a college that has this laptop purchase program: students get a choice between Mac and a Dell laptop, and unless you're a fine-arts major you don't get the Mac option. More likely, employees would be forced to buy the one computer that IT specifies. And, knowing how much VB.NET code is running out there now, it'll end up being a top-of-the-line enterprise Dell laptop, crippled with XP and all of their network policies. Somebody who's forced to buy a laptop and then give all control away won't be a happy body.
- gcheong 16y agoI think IT often overestimates the actual extra burden that would be required to support more devices and the risks associated. At the last company I worked at there were calls for people to be publicly made "examples of" for running Firefox as it was deemed too much of a support burden to have to support both IE and Firefox and a security threat. Then they found out the CEO had installed it and their tone changed from calling for a witch hunt to a begrudged "you can run it but we won't support it".
- Natsu 16y agoIf they're firing people for using Firefox, that's one thing. That's just absurd. But having people bring in their home computers that might be virus-infected or part of a botnet to work? Err, no. I've had more than one home computer brought to me to fix and I have never once let them on the network. I don't need to find out that the next Sasser/Blaster/whatever is now rampaging through our internal network. That's not to say that there aren't people and companies (likely small ones) that couldn't handle this. But unless each person was a pretty decent computer admin who was not likely to install crapware, kept themselves patched, etc., I wouldn't trust them at all. But, like I said, I've seen the home machines of the people at work and I've removed viruses from them. There's no way I'd put them on our network even though I don't think there's anything they could infect. It's just not smart.
- maxawaytoolong 16y agoTradesmen provide their own tools if they are independently employed. If they are employed directly through a big firm, the firm often buys all their equipment for them, including a loaner truck and cell phone.
- techsupporter 16y agoThe majority of applications being remotely virtualized in this manner are/will be general business applications--word processor, spreadsheet, etc--or line of business applications such as CRM or ticket management systems. These don't need much horsepower, and, in the case of Citrix-based application virtualization, can run on the providing server ("streamed") or have the bits delivered locally to the client for it to execute. I think Microsoft's App-V (SoftGrid) works the same way, but I'm unsure if it does streaming or just packaged delivery. Either way, a pool laptop need not be that powerful to "keep up with the Jonses'" who bought their own.
- Splines 16y agoFrom what I've seen, App-V is on-demand packaged delivery. If you access a binary and it's not on your system (or needs to be updated), it'll download then execute locally.
- tedunangst 16y agoIf you're in the kind of job where your job performance will be substantially impacted by the newness of your computer, you should also be earning enough to afford a new computer considerably sooner than your first performance review.
- Leynos 16y agoThere are various reasons why that may not be the case. For example, the employee may have had the misfortune of recently having been made redundant and subsequently spent their savings and accumulated debt whilst searching for a new job.
- tedunangst 16y agoAnd maybe they don't have a car to get to work, or shiny shoes to match their suit, or a dozen other things which cost more than the computer they probably already have.
- Leynos 16y agoSuits can be found in charity shops and shoes are cheap if you buy them in end of season sales. Whether or not you drive to work is down to necessity I guess. For some it's a necessary evil, especially if they live and work a long way apart. I don't really see how this applies. Some people are fortunate that they may be able to afford to buy a computer for work, others less so. It's not a one size fits all situation, and whether or not the speed of someone's workstation would make a difference to their job hasn't much bearing on it. Of course, the article is confused between people working via remote desktop and people providing their own compute power, which kind of muddies the topic. I have done work in the past on my own machine of course, but I think for companies to come to expect this is placing an unhealthy burden on the employee. Personal machines are not necessarily reliable, nor can they often be repaired or replaced at short notice. If I was required to take work home, I would prefer to have a machine dedicated to that purpose, and I certainly wouldn't be happy about the idea of having to provide it myself. Where remote access is concerned, it becomes more a matter of preference. A faster machine in this instance is unlikely to make much difference, so this becomes less of an issue. Here an employee providing their own machine would be doing it more for personal preference or comfort.
- ghaff 16y agoThis sounds a bit dramatic given that laptop computers fully capable of running typical business applications are no more than $1K these days (and can be quite a bit less). There are lots of things you may need to (or be advantaged by) spending money on depending on the job. For example, if you're in a sales job in certain industries, you'll need to spend quite a bit of money on clothing (suits, etc.). Relatively few companies supply cell phones today, although some may pay for data plans. Maybe commuting to your job is the only reason you need a car. There are certainly complexities to bring-your-own-PC programs, especially with less technically savvy users, but the personal cost aspect isn't really one of them. (Especially given that most such programs have a subsidy.)
- FluidDjango 16y agoNote the alternative presented: "Citrix gives staff a stipend and they then buy the computer of their choice." That would work for me (as an employee). However, if I ran a despotic company where employees were apt to act out against "the man" I'd be pretty nervous about letting Pandora bring in her own box, so to speak.
- fleitz 16y agoWhen I worked as an employee I felt my job performance was hampered by the company policy of what went into the computers. (eg. they were crap). I swapped out just about every component I could in those machines, some funded by the company, some funded personally. Most professionals are expected to maintain their own tools. Most mechanics have their own tools, having the tools you like to use at your disposal is essential to doing a good job. The tools are also far more expensive than a computer. Personally, I would have loved to be able to bring my own computer to work and would have allowed me to drop the hassle of trying to hide the improvements I was making to their dev machine. Buying your own computer in dev is kind of like a lawyer buying his own suits. It may affect his job if he doesn't look sharp. There are lots of places to work and if the place you work at doesn't recognize the additional productivity you have gained from buying good tools then perhaps it is not the place one should work.
- lylejohnson 16y agoAt my job I had the choice of the company buying me a Windows-based Dell notebook, or just using my own personal MacBook Pro that I paid for; I chose the latter. Sometimes I get a little riled up about the fact that they didn't offer to reimburse me for the expense, but on the other hand I'm glad that I wasn't forced to use the same tools everyone else does.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- T-hawk 16y agoMost professionals have and maintain their own tools -- but tools in most other professions if poorly secured can't emit malware that sabotages everybody else's tools.
- mturmon 16y agoMachinists don't maintain their own lathes. My point is, I think there a lot of examples on both sides. A reasonable company should not argue about a $1.5K versus $3K laptop when they're paying so much more for salary, benefits, and overhead for the person using the system. At my workplace these total around $250K-$280K per person per year.
- gcheong 16y agoAn alternative way to do this is for you to go buy your choice of equipment then get reimbursed by the company for the expense within a reasonable limit. I imagine this keeps it as a pre-tax expense for the company as well. One could argue that how it is now it's still "your" money that gets spent anyway since you need a computer to work - it's just that the company spends it for you and gives you no choice in the matter.
- SoftwareMaven 16y agoI worked at a company that tried this in the late nineties. They ran afoul tax and accounting problems, since it wasn't seen as a business expense but rather more like a bonus since you kept the hardware if you left the company.
- acconrad 16y agoYou know you can just ask your company for ergonomic hardware, right? Companies have ergonomics guides and have to abide by them. If you have an uncomfortable chair, or a keyboard/mouse that brings about early signs of carpel tunnel, you have the right to request a new keyboard/mouse at the expense of the company. It's in the company's best interest to avoid (at best) paying long-term disability from you being injured and (at worst) a lawsuit for providing tools that injure you on the job and refusing to help you alleviate the pain.
- joeguilmette 16y agoI bought a new MacBook Air on my own dime for company use. Beats the hell out of a 3 y/o $400 frankenbox running XP. Worth every penny.