3 ms·
I remember in the 90s IBM started packaging and selling Apache web server. Some of my colleagues thought this was bad. But I went to ApacheCon and they were tot
by prepend 7y ago
I remember in the 90s IBM started packaging and selling Apache web server. Some of my colleagues thought this was bad. But I went to ApacheCon and they were totally cool with it. There was a good talk, I think by Jim Jajielski, explaining that the purpose of the Apache license is to allow this.
I don’t get these articles because it seems like “duh, that’s the point.” Either the press is stupid, or the companies are acting in bad faith, or the founders didn’t understand OSS, or something because cloud giants are doing nothing wrong. It’s permissible under the license of the named software.
It’s like complaining that Apple and Google sell phones with Unix stuff in there without licensing it. There’s no requirement to pay and no expectation.
Separately weird is that these cloud giants make tons of contributions to open source.
- cxr 7y agoFrom [1]: > People throw around the phrase "cognitive dissonance" lot, too loosely probably. But BSD folks who constantly tout the virtues of their license for the things that it allows downstream developers to do and then complain when someone actually exercises those options are the single best real world example of cognitive dissonance that I've ever encountered. 1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12618977 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12618977 Or to put it in meme format. Copyleft: ∗exists∗ Developers: ptui, MIT all the way Cloud giants: oh hey, nice code Developers: wait stahp
- znpy 7y agothis is the cleanest explaination to all that's going on right now. The harsh truth is that Stallman had seen it right all along, and adviced us on time about what to do. Yet not all of us listened, many gave in into non-completely-free licenses, and here we are now.
- thomascgalvin 7y agoThere are a lot of issues with Stallman, but when it comes to software freedom, the guy has been more right, more consistently, than anyone else. The fact that he advocated for "GPL Vx, or any later version" shows how much foresight he had; he even realized that he probably hadn't foreseen every issue, and included a mechanism for fixing it, and rolling out that patch more or less automatically.
- heavenlyblue 7y agoI believe most of the developers who love coding would easily agree with Stallman. Unfortunately most of the world doesn’t care about code and they have every reason to be that way. So strategic decisions that push us towards less optimal minima are quite expected. TL;DR humanity doesn’t care about the pipe dream where everyone knows how to program and change things for themselves. they want finished products that do something.
- convolvatron 7y agoi generally understood it to go more like this: BSD-style developer wrote some code to scratch an itch developer finds company taking the source and tweaking it to make proprietary product developer and their friends land nice consulting gigs and/or full time jobs
- gregwebs 7y ago> Separately weird is that these cloud giants make tons of contributions to open source In some cases a cloud provider makes millions of dollars from a particular open source project and gives nothing back to it. This is the behavior that concerns many. It is also easy to see this as against the spirit of the GPL license, even if projects should switch to AGPL if that is really the case.
- skybrian 7y agoIt's open source, so you can "pay it forward" by contributing to other open source projects. There is no expectation you contribute back to each project you use.
- cameronbrown 7y agoIf Amazon makes millions selling MongoDB, then aren't they just promoting MongoDB's ecosystem and tool development? The same way it's good for the MySQL (and broader SQL-based DB) ecosystem because new tools will be built around these systems' interfaces. Sure, they should contribute back, but it's not like they won't be indirectly encouraging others to contribute instead.
- JetSpiegel 7y agoShould mom-and-pop computer shops just pirate Windows? After all, they are just promoting Microsoft's ecosystem. If the license requires contribution (code for GPL, cash for Windows), abide by the license. Of course, if some companies give away their code using non freedom-preserving licenses and get cannibalized by other larger companies, it's just the free market punishing the ignorant.
- cameronbrown 7y ago> Should mom-and-pop computer shops just pirate Windows? After all, they are just promoting Microsoft's ecosystem. Of course not, but I'd argue Windows, Photoshop and the like are more popular because of pirates who went on to use the software professionally because, yes, they are promoting the ecosystem. Just think of the number of Windows app developers who developed upon a pirated copy.