5 ms·
This topic reminds me of an Ebert review of Solaris (2002): The genius of Lem's underlying idea is that the duplicates, or replicants, or whatever we choose to
by keiferski 7y ago
This topic reminds me of an Ebert review of Solaris (2002):
The genius of Lem's underlying idea is that the duplicates, or replicants, or whatever we choose to call them, are self-conscious and seem to carry on with free will from the moment they are evoked by the planet. Rheya, for example, says, "I'm not the person I remember. I don't remember experiencing these things." And later, "I'm suicidal because that's how you remember me." In other words, Kelvin gets back not his dead wife, but a being who incorporates all he knows about his dead wife, and nothing else, and starts over from there. She has no secrets because he did not know her secrets. If she is suicidal, it is because he thought she was.
The deep irony here is that all of our relationships in the real world are exactly like that, even without the benefit of Solaris. We do not know the actual other person. What we know is the sum of everything we think we know about them. Even empathy is perhaps of no use; we think it helps us understand how other people feel, but maybe it only tells us how we would feel, if we were them.
https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/solaris-2002 https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/solaris-2002
I think it is a deep mistake to correlate one's exterior appearance and behavior with a sense of selfhood. At best, it's a shallow surface imitation of the actual person. At worst, it creates a nightmarish, Uncanny Valley-esque simulacrum, not unlike Harlow's wire monkey mother surrogates. It would be better to learn how to accept and deal with loss - a reality that everyone inevitably faces.
- duxup 7y agoIn the end of Solaris (at least the American version) it seems the protagonist chooses the illusion. Right or wrong perhaps the illusion is enough / or all we really know.
- walterstucco 7y agoThe movie's finale (both) is not what happen in the book. In the book Kelvin accepts that he's standing in front of a godlike creature that the human mind will never understand, he surrender, lands on the planet's surface hoping that "time of cruel miracles was not past". The acceptance is not of the illusion itself, but of the fact that we would never understand the whys, the rational thinking and scientific positivism have become the real illusion, all is lost, Solaris won, there is only the hope that Solaris will keep making "cruel miracles".
- duxup 7y agoThat sure sounds like he is ok with such miracles as far as living his life from there out. He doesn't understand them anymore than he understood the people who were created, or the real people. I always thought that was the point, to ask if his mind couldn't be used to create the other person....then did he really know them? Can anyone.
- danidiaz 7y ago"And yet, if only from my dreams when I was asleep, I might have learned that my grief for my grandmother's death was diminishing, for she appeared in them less crushed by the idea that I had formed of her non-existence. I saw her an invalid still, but on the road to recovery, I found her in better health. And if she made any allusion to what she had suffered, I stopped her mouth with my kisses and assured her that she was now permanently cured. I should have liked to call the sceptics to witness that death is indeed a malady from which one recovers. Only, I no longer found in my grandmother the rich spontaneity of old times. Her words were no more than a feeble, docile response, almost a mere echo of mine; she was nothing more than the reflexion of my own thoughts." —Marcel Proust, Cities of the Plain
- texuf 7y ago"And yet, if only from my dreams when I was asleep, I might have learned that my grief for my grandmother's death was diminishing, for she appeared in them less crushed by the idea that I had formed of her non-existence. I saw her an invalid still, but on the road to recovery, I found her in better health. And if she made any allusion to what she had suffered, I stopped her mouth with my kisses and assured her that she was now permanently cured. I should have liked to call the sceptics to witness that death is indeed a malady from which one recovers. Only, I no longer found in my grandmother the rich spontaneity of old times. Her words were no more than a feeble, docile response, almost a mere echo of mine; she was nothing more than the reflexion of my own thoughts." —Marcel Proust, Cities of the Plain
- fossuser 7y agoThere's a similar plot in the Black Mirror episode "Be Right Back" (from an earlier season when it was still UK only).