3 ms·
To play devil's advocate, one important difference is that brains are not (yet) networked. We don't have telepathy, you can't communicate with other people usin
by xg15 7y ago
To play devil's advocate, one important difference is that brains are not (yet) networked. We don't have telepathy, you can't communicate with other people using your brain alone, so you cannot use it to coordinate terrorist attack either - whereas with encrypted messengers, you absolutely can.
... not that I'd expect this point to make any difference if the technology to inspect brains were on the horizon.
- ignoramous 7y agoThe thought experiment does well to answer 'I have nothing to hide, only criminals do' mindset, imo.
- mnem 7y agoSurely language is how brains communicate? Terrorists were (and still are) quite capable of coordinated attacks without digital technologies.
- xg15 7y agoWell, I was talkig about literally "the brain". Even for language, you need a mouth attached to that. My point is that having a brain is not enough to communicate - you also need some kind of transmission medium that connects you to other brains. So even if you would agree to the opinion that any and all communication must be monitored (because terrorists), that would still no allow you to monitor the brain, because the brain itself is not what enables communication. Monitoring a smartphone would be more justified because you legitimately need access to it to monitor an end-to-end-encrapted connection. (My "devil's advocate" was to note that brains and smartphones are not equivalent, not that monitoring brains should be allowed. On the contrary, my point is that even if you were ok with monitoring smartphones, there are still arguments against monitoring brains.)
- coldtea 7y ago>you can't communicate with other people using your brain alone, so you cannot use it to coordinate terrorist attack either You can use it to plan and carry one on your own though. And of course you'll know about an attack if your team is organizing one. Shouldn't all people get brain-screened (from experienced TSA brain scanning operators) to ensure the government gets that information?
- Broken_Hippo 7y agoSure, if it is simple enough or your plans are simple enough. Otherwise, most folks at least use paper because actual terrorist plans are complicated with lots of bits.
- meowface 7y agoAt least some number of people will have the crucial parts of the plan in their minds, though. The parts that could thwart the whole plot if those parts were to be discovered by law enforcement. Of course, law enforcement may not know who those people are or even that an attack is imminent without pre-emptively monitoring every single person's thoughts so it can be detected with sufficient time to stop it, like how cop cars and (I think) speed cameras pre-emptively and automatically scan every license plate they can detect.