> By your logic, I am not the brain because I am observing its activity. But without it I am nothing, how does that work out? I don't know your relationship wi

> By your logic, I am not the brain because I am observing its activity. But without it I am nothing, how does that work out? I don't know your relationship with the concept of "soul" (and I'm writing this way to be careful), but many of us sometimes find it really useful to be able to talk about who we really are.